When a tunnel is built to kill rather than connect, it is not infrastructure — it is a perversion of purpose, and Bion’s “thoughts without a thinker” tells us exactly why.
Fig. 12 The misuse of an object, i.e. the tunnel constitutes a perversion.
A reader from the UK compared Hamas’s “Metro” to the London Tube—both feats of male determination and machinery. The analogy collapses once the unconscious intent is examined. The Tube was built within democracy to connect and sustain life; Hamas’s tunnels were carved under tyranny to kidnap, smuggle, and kill. One is infrastructure. The other, weaponized regression.
Wilfred Bion, psychoanalyst and WWI decorated tank commander, warned that without early trust, adults act from suspicion, not responsibility—“thoughts without a thinker.” Hamas operates on this level: splitting, projection, magical thinking—tunnels as birth canals, leaders as psychotic mothers. Unlike the IDF, a working group bound by accountability, Hamas is a non-working group held together by scapegoating and internal violence.
TAKEAWAY:
• The London Tube was built to connect and serve.
• Hamas’s tunnel system was built to destroy and possess.
• One expresses maturity and civic responsibility; the other expresses regression and dependency.
• Hamas’s tunnels are not infrastructure—they are perversions of purpose.
— Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD
A Soldier’s Guide to Hamas’s Genocidal Psychosis: The Unconscious in Psychological Warfare — Beyond Ideology, Before Words



