Fig. 29 The Maternal Ritualized Rooftop Expulsion
As a PTSD expert focusing not only on the patients but as significantly on the mind of the predator, I estimate that this information will help 5-10% of those who have a need to understand the terror in detail. In turn this knowledge will have a ripple effect.
FIELD NOTE / OBSERVATION
Jihad’s rooftop killings are never random. The victims they select—gay men and elderly Jewish women—represent the parts of the self Hamas cannot tolerate: vulnerability, dependence, tenderness, softness, memory, and above all the maternal witness, ummi. These qualities threaten the regressed, fused, dysfunctional group self—the hollow herd.
The hollow herd inhabits not only a physical desert but a psychic desert—an arid inner landscape stripped of imagination, creativity, and nourishment. In contrast, the Jewish world is experienced as a land “flowing with milk and honey,” symbolically fertile—a contrast that fuels unbearable envy. Rooftop murder becomes a way to destroy what they cannot cultivate inside themselves.
Everybody carries a deep dread of falling—the preverbal terror that the caretaking figure will drop you or let you fall into psychic oblivion. Hamas re-enacts this dread literally: by throwing bodies off rooftops, they become the one who drops, not the one dropped. Rooftop murder is displaced matricide—revenge on the mother who “let them fall,” enacted upon chosen Others.
The attacker is not acting individually; he is the herd’s scapegoat-carrier, performing the group’s disowned destructiveness. The fall itself is central: gravity becomes the executioner. The descent stages the psychological collapse Hamas fears internally—the collapse of boundaries, autonomy, symbolization, and selfhood. Into the victim they evacuate unbearable inner states: shame, dependency, helplessness, tenderness, ambiguity.
These killings are regulatory, disciplining the group through terror. The message is unmistakable: any qualities associated with humanity—conscience, softness, individuality, memory—will be annihilated. The rooftop becomes a psychological tribunal; the dread of falling weaponized into public pedagogy. Every member of the hollow herd hears the warning: you could be next.
TAKEAWAY
• Hamas targets gay and elderly Jewish women because they embody vulnerability, dependence, memory, and the accusatory eye of ummi—the internal witness the hollow herd must expel.
• The attacker acts as the herd’s scapegoat, enacting the group’s disowned rage, shame, and envy.
• The hollow herd rejects any qualities that threaten its regressed, fused, dysfunctional group self, shaped by an arid inner landscape that cannot tolerate creativity, tenderness, or symbolization.
• Throwing bodies from rooftops is a ritualized evacuation of unbearable inner states—shame, dependency, softness, and the dreaded early fall.
• Gravity performs the collapse Hamas fears inside, transforming psychological dread into literal descent.
• These murders function as internal discipline, warning every member of the herd that ambiguity, conscience, or humanity will be annihilated.
(Insight on the “dread of falling” informed by Alina Schellekes.)
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD
nancykobrin.org
A Soldier’s Guide to Hamas’s Genocidal Psychosis (Atzmaut Press, Tel Aviv, 2025)
*Today I have coined the term: “Psychoanalytic Visual Intelligence” – no one to the best of my knowledge has ever used this term.
Stay tuned for tomorrow’s posting of Hamas’s genocidal saga: The Unconscious Meaning of “The Intifada.”




