This morning I wrote about the two children of Fatten Elkomy: the daughter who remembers the family’s Muslim Brotherhood past out loud, and the son, Abdul El-Sayed, who told Meet the Press that his family had no such ties. What I did not say is what lies beneath that denial. Beneath concealment lies shame.
Guilt says, I did something wrong. Shame says, I must not be seen. In an honor-shame culture, exposure is itself the injury, and hiding the family’s secret feels not like lying but like protecting its honor. That is why the denial comes so fast. And it is not only shame. In January, the United States designated the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, the movement his mother was active in as a student, a terrorist organization. A man running for the United States Senate knows what that word means for his candidacy, so his no also shows intent. For the son, the mother’s Brotherhood past is not a political fact to be explained. It is a shame to be kept out of sight. The daughter can say it with pride. The son can only say no.
“Are You Circumcised?”
Shame has a second face. What cannot be borne in oneself is often turned outward, onto someone else, who is then made to feel exposed, by means of projection. On August 24th, El-Sayed appeared on Jesse Watters Primetime on Fox News. Watters pressed him on gender surgery for minors and asked whether parents should be allowed to “slash their kid’s ding-a-ling off.” El-Sayed answered with a question of his own: “Are you circumcised?” When Watters called it a personal question, El-Sayed went on: “Circumcision is surgery on a kid’s ding-a-ling.”
His argument was about consistency. If parents may choose circumcision for an infant, he was saying, why not other decisions about a child’s body? One can debate that argument on its merits. Watters called it “wacky,” and answered that circumcision is different from castration. What interests me as a psychoanalyst is not the policy but the move. Asked about his own position, El-Sayed did not explain it. He turned the question around and pointed it at the other man’s body. The one being questioned became the one asking, and the interviewer was suddenly the one exposed.
Put the two scenes side by side. On Meet the Press, asked about his own family, he conceals. On Fox News, asked about children’s bodies, he exposes someone else. These are not opposites. They are the two faces of the same shame. What is hidden in oneself is uncovered in another.
And the question he chose is not an innocent one. Circumcision means something very different in the two traditions. El-Sayed did not mention Judaism, but its practice was there by implication. In Judaism it is the covenant itself, the brit milah commanded to Abraham in Genesis, performed on the eighth day of a boy’s life. In Islam it is not a covenant. Khitan is not mentioned in the Qur’an. It belongs to the sunna, among the practices of fitra, the innate nature with which, in Islamic teaching, every child is born, inclined toward belief in God. It is traced back to Abraham through hadith, and in much of the Muslim world it has traditionally been done later in childhood, often as a public rite of passage. To ask a man whether he is circumcised is still to ask whose people he belongs to. In Europe, that question was once asked by men with guns, who stripped Jewish men to find out. I do not suggest El-Sayed had any of this in mind. That is the point. What the unconscious reaches for is rarely chosen.
The difference in timing matters to a psychoanalyst. The Jewish boy is cut on the eighth day, before conscious memory. Where the Muslim boy is cut later, often after the age of seven, when he leaves the world of the mother for the world of the men, he can remember it. The cut marks the separation from the mother, and it is witnessed, celebrated and sometimes feared. It is fitting, and telling, that a man who cannot speak about his mother’s past reaches, under pressure, for the mark a family leaves on a boy’s body at the moment it takes him from his mother. The family’s history is written there too.
The Insult, Then the Hand
Shame also wears a third face: passive aggressive behavior. It is the hardest behavior to confront because it happens so quickly. The blow arrives disguised as something else, a policy point, a joke, a question, and by the time the other person registers that he has been hit, the moment has passed and the aggressor looks reasonable. El-Sayed did it to Watters. He did it again last week, when NewsNation’s Leland Vittert asked him whether Israel or Iran was the bigger threat to the United States. He called it a “dumb question,” then hastily offered to shake Vittert’s hand. The insult, then the hand. That is passive aggression in two gestures.
El-Sayed is quick, articulate and, as even Watters admitted, compelling. But a candidate who meets hard questions by concealing his own family and exposing his questioner’s body is showing us something. Shame does not stay hidden. It comes out sideways, in a question no one expected, on live television.
Sources
Mediaite, “Fox News Interview Takes Bizarre Turn When Abdul El-Sayed Asks Jesse Watters, ‘Are You Circumcised?’,” August 24, 2026. https://www.mediaite.com/media/tv/fox-news-interview-takes-bizarre-turn-when-abdul-el-sayed-asks-jesse-watters-are-you-circumcised/
Daily Caller, “’Are You Circumcised?’: Abdul El-Sayed’s Interview With Jesse Watters Goes Off The Rails,” August 25, 2026. https://dailycaller.com/2026/08/25/abdul-el-sayed-jesse-watters-fox-news-circumcision/
The Daily Beast, “Fox Host Jesse Watters Responds After Bonkers NSFW Interview With Dem Star Abdul El-Sayed,” August 2026. https://www.thedailybeast.com/fox-host-jesse-watters-responds-after-bonkers-nsfw-interview-with-dem-star-abdul-el-sayed/
Jewish Insider, “Trump admin designates three branches of Muslim Brotherhood as terror organizations,” January 2026. https://jewishinsider.com/2026/01/muslim-brotherhood-terror-organization-executive-order/
Genesis 17:9–14 (the covenant of circumcision).
Abe Greenwald, “El-Sayed in the Harsh Light,” Commentary, October 12, 2026.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar. https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y#AbdulElSayed #JesseWatters #Circumcision #Shame #PassiveAggression #MuslimBrotherhood #Michigan #Senate2026 #Psychoanalysis #Projection


