Twenty-four hours after apologizing to Michigan’s Jewish Democratic caucus, Abdul El-Sayed apologized again — this time directly to JTA, saying he wished he could “take it all the way back.” A person doing real repair apologizes once and holds it. A person running a maintenance procedure has to keep re-issuing it, because each version manages only the room in front of him at that moment and never accumulates into anything stable. The second apology isn’t proof of deepening remorse. It’s proof the first one was a non-apology.
Detroit Rabbi Asher Lopatin said as much directly, calling the apology a non-apology: El-Sayed still hasn’t recognized Israel’s legitimacy as a Jewish state, still hasn’t denounced Hasan Piker, still hasn’t retracted calling Israel “bloodthirsty.” That’s the substance the tone never touches. Rabbi Lopatin said this one day after I had already published my own piece on the matter at Substack.
What connects the apology, the second apology, and the taxes-and-bombs line underneath both of them isn’t a personality trait. It’s a psychological structural requirement of a predator — the kind this type needs a stable object to organize itself around, the way a building needs a foundation whether or not anyone looks at it. The object stays fixed across every register, apology included: Israel, “Israeli,” the Jew, Zionist, Genocidaire behind the word.
A predator returns to what and whom still feeds something in him; this type returns to what still organizes something in him. Neither return is optional, which is why the apology never closes anything — closing it would mean giving up the object, and the object is load-bearing. Indeed the “feeding” is on the order of DARVO, deny attack reverse victim offender; here bloodthirsty refers to him feeding on Jews.
Predatory behavior has a second signature beyond obsession: isolation. A predator does not simply return to the object — he works to separate it and whom from what protects it. Here the object is not an abstraction. It is the American Jewish voter, and what protects that voter is her ordinary, unremarkable attachment to Israel as a homeland and a fact of Jewish peoplehood. El-Sayed’s project, apology included, is not to leave that attachment alone. It is to work it loose — caucus by caucus, apology by apology — persuading Jewish Democrats that criticizing Israel and staying loyal to their own community are not just compatible but required of them. Rebecca Kasen’s shift from reluctant to enthusiastic is not evidence the apology worked. It is evidence the isolation is working: a Jewish voter one degree further from her own instinctive defense of Israel than she was the week before.
He did not make one approach. He addressed the convention on Saturday, gave a second apology to JTA on Sunday, and was set to appear that same weekend at a caucus gathering honoring Attorney General Dana Nessel — three separate approaches to the same community within days. That is not persistence in service of dialogue. It is the stalking pattern: repeated, patterned contact with a target whose resistance is worn down by proximity and familiarity, not persuaded by argument.
This is not a portrait of one man. It’s a description of a type now operating throughout Woke 2.0, and El-Sayed is simply its clearest specimen on the public record this week.
There are strategic and tactical approaches to confronting Abdul’s predatory hatred — political, legal, electoral. This is not that. This is a developmental, descriptive analysis, offered because some people need to understand the problem in a detailed way before they can decide not only what to do about it but how to disengage one’s self from the chronic abuse of the negative projection and to shake off the stalker.
Source: Jewish Journal, “Michigan Rabbi Says El-Sayed’s Apology is a Non-Apology”
Dr. Kobrin is a counterterrorism expert and psychoanalyst holding a PhD in Islamic literature. She is a graduate of the Human Terrain Program, Leavenworth, KS. Her most recent book is A Soldier’s Guide to Hamas’s Genocidal Psychosis: The Unconscious in Psychological Warfare -- Beyond Ideology, Before Words. Atzmaut Press 2025. She is currently working on her seventh book Between Empire and Covenant—The Jewish Bond: Lotman, The Refuseniks and The Bukharan Jews, 1977. See her full body of work at her Amazon author page: https://www.amazon.com/stores/author/B002RF9D5Y


