On Monday, ABC News asked Abdul El-Sayed, Michigan’s Democratic nominee for the U.S. Senate, a plain question: is Israel an American ally? He did not answer with a treaty, a vote, or a policy. He answered with a story about a child.
Israel, he said, is like the friend who keeps sponging off your kids’ money, talks about them behind their backs, and drags them into fights with their other friends. Then he turned to the reporter: “What would you tell your kid?” His answer was that it is time to admit Israel is not our friend.
The story he tells about Israel is the story he will not tell about his own family.
His Personal Fairy Tale
Watch the move. A Senate candidate asked about foreign policy reaches for his personal fairy tale. America becomes the parent, Americans become the children, and Israel becomes the bad companion who exploits them and leads them astray. Politics turns into a family drama with a seducer at its center. Now hold his three charges against Israel next to what Abdul himself has been asked about.
Whose Family?
The bad friend takes the children’s money. Start there, because this is the oldest antisemitic trope in the book: the Jew as moneylender and parasite, living off the host nation and bleeding it dry. Abdul does not say “Jew.” He says “Israel,” and puts it in his personal fairy tale, where the old poison goes down easily. But the image is the same one Europe told for centuries.
Then look at his own house. From 1999 to 2004, Abdul’s mother, Fatten Elkomy, worked for the Islamic American Relief Agency, a group the U.S. Treasury designated for financing terror. The question of where money went, and whom it served, belongs to his family’s record, not Israel’s.
The bad friend talks about them behind their backs. This is a second antisemitic image, rooted in Islamic tradition: in the Quran, the Jews who twist their tongues and distort words (Sura 4:46), and in the Hadith, the Jew hiding behind the stone and the tree, the Hadith Hamas placed in its charter. The Jew is the one who conceals, speaks falsely, and hides.
Then look again at his own family. This month Abdul denied his family’s ties to the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, while his own half-sister had posted about those ties openly. What is said inside the family is one thing. What he says in public is another.
The bad friend drags the children into fights with their other friends. Now comes the news that his sister-in-law, Miriam Jukaku, was involved in a federal terrorist watchlist lawsuit during the Obama administration. He told Fox she had done nothing wrong, blamed Islamophobia, and laid the fault at the feet of his Republican opponent, Mike Rogers.
Each accusation he throws at Israel lands on a question he refuses to answer at home. This is projection: what cannot be looked at in one’s own house is expelled and then found in someone else. Here it is found in the Jewish state.
Then, on Monday, a campaign field organizer was fired after an undercover video caught him saying Abdul cannot reject Hamas because “he’s going to lose the people that brought him up in the first place.” The campaign calls his remarks untrue, and they are one man’s words. But listen to the phrase. “The people that brought him up” describes a political base, and it is also how one speaks of family. The same organizer worried that Jewish advisers might “hijack” the candidate. There again is the Jew working behind the scenes.
Think DARVO Again
Readers of my earlier pieces will recognize the sequence. In August, after his “hurt people hurt people” remark about the Temple Israel attack, Abdul apologized to Michigan’s Jewish Democrats. Seven weeks later he tells a national audience that Israel is not our friend. Deny, attack, reverse victim and offender. The non-apology was the setup. This is the payoff.
The reversal runs deeper. In his telling, Israel takes the money and starts the fights. In the world, it was Israel’s children who were slaughtered on October 7, kidnapped and held in tunnels, and it is Jewish children in America who now need guards outside their schools and synagogues. The bad friend in his story is the one who was attacked.
Where the Story Begins
Why a fairy tale? What a person reaches for under pressure comes from the earliest layers of the mind, the unseen years from birth to age three, when we learn who protects us and who endangers us long before we have words for it. A child is told whom to fear before he can judge for himself. The need for an enemy, as Vamik Volkan, the Turkish Cypriot Muslim Psychoanalyst, showed, is in place by age three and steadies a fragile self. Later it finds its target and holds on: Israel, Israeli, Jew, Zionist, Genocidaire.
I am not diagnosing Abdul El-Sayed. I am describing a type within Woke 2.0, and the public record of what this candidate says, does, and refuses to look at. His own metaphor raises a question he has spent four decades avoiding. In the unseen years, when a child first learns whom to trust and whom to fear, the one who held him was his mother, Fatten Elkomy. The same mother later worked for a charity that financed terror. In his fairy tale, the danger is never a mother. It is a friend, moved outside the home and given the name Israel.
What Michigan Must Do
Rabbis and Jewish leaders have asked the Democratic Party to commit to nonnegotiable principles for Jewish safety. University of Michigan students who identify as Democrats have joined them. Good. But principles on paper do not reach the level where this story lives. The task is to name it. When a candidate describes Israel as the bad friend who corrupts the children, he is telling a story about his own household and placing it on the Jews.
Michigan voters do not have to accept his personal fairy tale. In every fairy tale, the child is warned about the wolf. In Abdul’s, the wolf was named for him in childhood, and its name is Israel. So answer his question honestly. What would you tell your kid? Be wary of the man who hands you a fairy tale in place of the truth about his own family.
Source: Ariella Roitman, “’Israel is not our friend’: Michigan’s El-Sayed doubles down on anti-Israel stance,” The Jerusalem Post, October 20, 2026.
Reuven Rosenfeld, “El-Sayed Campaign Organizer Fired After Undercover Video Alleges Overseas Donations and Hamas Concerns,” VINnews, October 19, 2026.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y




It has been happening for a long time. It only has "surfaced" so it is more visible.
https://substack.com/@robertmoisescu/note/c-382078877?r=7a02yu