He calls his sister’s account hearsay and reporters’ questions dumb. He says he has never asked his mother.
Abdul El-Sayed told NBC’s Tom Llamas: “I have never had these conversations with my mother.”
Llamas had asked whether his mother, Fatten Elkomy, had ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. His half-sister, Eman Abdelhadi, has written that the family has “long been” connected to the Brotherhood and that their mother was active in it as a college student in Egypt in the 1970s. El-Sayed called that “hearsay evidence from a tweet.”
Hearsay from whom? His own sister, speaking about their own mother.
This is not a son who says he has no contact with his mother. He called her in a Mother’s Day campaign video. He sent money for her birthday gift. He stood as his sister’s wali, or male guardian, at her 2016 Sharia wedding, with their mother present. Yet he says he has never asked her about her past.
It is a pattern. When a Free Press reporter asked about the Iranian regime, he told her to “ask smart questions.” He called the question of whether Israel or Iran is the bigger threat to America “dumb” and a “ridiculous hypothetical.” On a leaked campaign call, he declined to comment on Khamenei’s death, saying “there are a lot of people in Dearborn who are sad today.” When questions touch a difficult subject, he turns the scrutiny back on the person asking: “Are you serious?”
On last night’s Commentary podcast, John Podhoretz, Seth Mandel, and Abe Greenwald repeated a common shorthand: Abdul was raised by his father and stepmother, so his mother did not raise him. But that skips over the unseen years—from pregnancy through age three—when the brain is developing rapidly and a child’s earliest sense of security is taking shape through relationships with caregivers. The brain does not stop developing at three, and science cannot tell us which caregiver mattered most to Abdul. But those years are not nothing. Fatten formed his mind before he was taken from her arms and given to his father and stepmother.
Psychoanalyst Vamik Volkan, the famous Turkish Cypriot Muslim psychoanalyst, argued that the foundations for dividing the world into allies and enemies emerge in early childhood. That framework can’t diagnose El-Sayed or explain his answers. It does remind us why the earliest family history should not be waved away when we’re trying to understand how a person handles questions about identity, loyalty, and threat.
If El-Sayed wants voters to accept his answer about his family, why dismiss his sister’s account as hearsay without asking the person at its center?
A man who says he has never asked his mother about this history is asking Michigan to trust him with a Senate seat.
Sources
“‘Hearsay’: Abdul El-Sayed Dismisses Sister’s Claims About Family’s Muslim Brotherhood Activism,” Washington Free Beacon, October 15, 2026.
https://freebeacon.com/?p=2166565
Audrey Fahlberg, “Abdul El-Sayed’s Unanswered Questions,” The Free Press, October 12, 2026.
The Atlantic profile on El-Sayed’s upbringing: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/09/abdul-el-sayed-michigan-senate-profile/688576/
Harvard Center on the Developing Child, “8 Things to Remember about Child Development”: https://developingchild.harvard.edu/resources/8-things-remember-child-development/
Vamik Volkan, “The Need to Have Enemies and Allies: A Developmental Approach”: https://www.jstor.org/stable/3791020
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



