When terrorism experts want to understand an attack, they say follow the money. It is sound advice, and it traces the network that made the attack possible. But it never reaches the first network every terrorist belongs to: the bond with his mother. Hamam al-Hammami, the Flydubai copilot, asked his captain for time to pray, then attacked him from behind with the cockpit’s crash axe and sent a plane full of Israelis diving toward the Saudi desert, some 14,000 feet in 29 seconds. Of his family, we know only that his mother is Syrian. Her name has not been released. That silence is where my work begins, because the maternal bond is the attachment that terrorism recycles. The terrorist bonds to his enemy, violently, because the first bond failed him.
Days after Hammami’s attack, an EgyptAir pilot named Osama Mansour found himself taxiing beside an El Al plane at an airport in Italy. He did not look away. He filmed it, then posted the footage set to Anwar Sadat’s 1973 wartime speech: an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. One comment beneath it warned that this was only the beginning. Whatever Mansour intended, the gesture itself speaks, and reading such images is the work of what I call Psychoanalytic Visual Intelligence: attending to what a person shows us without knowing he is showing it. He could not leave the Israeli plane alone. He held it in his lens, wrapped it in his father’s generation’s war, and sent it out to be seen. This is what I mean when I say the terrorist bonds to us. The enemy becomes the object he cannot release, watched, recorded, returned to again and again, the way an infant who never received secure holding clings to what threatens him.
Mansour’s video is a portrait of obsession. Obsession is the mind’s refusal to let go of an object it cannot possess and cannot live without. It does not rest. It circles back, rehearses, keeps watch. When obsession leaves the mind and enters the world, it becomes stalking: pursuit of someone who never chose the relationship, surveillance disguised as chance encounter, the recording of the target’s movements, and finally the message meant to frighten, this is just the beginning. Stalking should not be mistaken for ordinary narcissism. The narcissist needs an audience; the stalker needs prey. Stalking is predatory behavior, patient, targeted and escalating, and it ends too often in violence. Clinicians know the stalker’s profile well. He is often someone who could not bear a separation, who experiences the other’s independent existence as an abandonment and an insult. The stalker does not hate a stranger. He hates someone he is bound to. Israel is that object for the jihadi mind, a separation that cannot be tolerated, a presence that must be watched, followed, and in the end destroyed. Mansour did not merely see an El Al plane. He tracked it, captured it, and displayed his capture. That is not a pilot’s idle curiosity. It is the stalker’s signature, and he signed it in public.
German reporting has long understood that the family is part of the story. After September 11, Der Spiegel sent a team to Cairo to interview Mohamed Atta’s father, a retired lawyer who insisted on his son’s innocence, and later obtained the family’s private photographs of the young Atta with his parents and sisters. After Anis Amri drove a truck into the Berlin Christmas market in 2016, German media carried the voices of his mother, Nour el-Houda, and his sister from the family home in Oueslatia, Tunisia, where he was the youngest of nine children. When Andreas Lubitz deliberately flew a Germanwings jet into the French Alps in 2015, reporters converged on his parents’ house in Montabaur, and the press learned that his mother played the organ at the local Lutheran church. Even the mothers who deny everything tell us something. Atta’s mother told a Spanish newspaper years later that she believed her son was still alive in Guantanamo. These journalists grasp what counterterrorism agencies rarely say aloud: the family is not background to the attack. It is where the attack begins.
There is a bitter irony in the news from Damascus. Ahmed al-Sharaa, the former jihadist who now rules Syria, is weighing whether to send Syrian fighters to Saudi Arabia to help the kingdom against the Houthis. Saudi Arabia is where Hammami’s plane came down, at Tabuk, after passengers wrestled him from the controls. If al-Sharaa wants to offer the Saudis something of real value, he should send Hammami’s mother instead. Not as a suspect, and not as a scapegoat, but as the one witness who knows the earliest chapter of her son’s life. Fighters can hold a border. Only she can tell us what happened in the years before her son learned to fly, when he first learned whom to love and whom to hate.
Every stalker watches before he strikes. Osama Mansour showed us the watching: the lens raised from one cockpit toward another, the footage replayed, the threat posted for all to see. Hamam al-Hammami showed us the strike: the axe, the dive, the plane full of Israelis pointed at the earth. Between them lies the whole arc of a bond gone wrong, from gaze to grip to destruction. Airlines screen pilots for alcohol, for medical fitness, for flight hours. No one screens for obsession, though it leaves a trail long before it reaches the cockpit, in what a man posts, what he films, what he cannot stop looking at. Investigators will follow the money, as they should. But the money only tells us who paid. The obsession tells us who is coming next. And the obsession begins where every bond begins, with the mother. Follow the money, and you find the network. Follow the mother, and you find the man.
Sources
Associated Press (Cara Anna), “A plumber and a dentist are praised as heroes in FlyDubai near-disaster,” Oct. 1, 2026. https://www.opb.org/article/2026/10/01/a-plumber-and-a-dentist-are-praised-as-heroes-in-flydubai-near-disaster/
CNN, “Report: Flydubai suspect removed by another airline over extremism concerns,” Oct. 2026. https://www.tmj4.com/us-news/report-flydubai-suspect-removed-by-another-airline-over-extremism-concerns
i24NEWS, “Vol flydubai : le copilote omanais décrit comme ‘introverti et très religieux’,” Oct. 2026. https://www.i24news.tv/fr/actu/international/moyen-orient/artc-vol-flydubai-le-copilote-omanais-decrit-comme-introverti-et-tres-religieux
VINnews (Yehuda Dov), “Former El Al Captain: 4 Separate Miracles Saved Flight 1073,” Oct. 8, 2026.
VINnews (Joseph Feldman), “EgyptAir Pilot Films El Al Plane, Posts ‘Eye for an Eye’ Audio,” Oct. 8, 2026.
Reuters via The Jerusalem Post, “Syria weighs military aid for Saudi Arabia amid war with Houthis, sources say,” Oct. 8, 2026.
Norbert Schiller, photographer’s account of Der Spiegel’s interview with Mohamed el-Amir Atta in Cairo. https://negativecolors.com/?p=3033
leinetal24 (dpa), “Jetzt spricht die Familie des mutmaßlichen Terroristen von Berlin,” Dec. 2016. https://www.leinetal24.de/welt/anschlag-jetzt-spricht-mutter-mumasslichen-terroristen-von-berlin-zr-7164800.html
Adnkronos, “Berlin Christmas market attack suspect’s family upset by his killing,” Dec. 2016. https://www.adnkronos.com/berlin-christmas-market-attack-suspects-family-upset-by-his-killing_1akoqBFVQEYLQ4ZD4y3eki
Reuters via IOL, “Crash co-pilot’s very ordinary life,” Mar. 26, 2015. https://www.iol.co.za/news/world/crash-co-pilots-very-ordinary-life-1837650
AFP via Egypt Independent, “9/11 pilot’s mother believes he is alive in Guantanamo.” https://www.egyptindependent.com/?p=2472517
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar. https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



You are right it is very hard to deter. They have to move away from a clan/hamula mentality that does not permit separation from the mother. They have to stop abusing their little females and prioritizing the male baby. The first thing is to educate policy makers etc to the problem. This is why Hamas won't disarm - developmentally their thinking arising during this crucial period of the unseen years. The weapon is like a psychological prothesis in their mind. They were never able to grow up and then their problem becomes ours. We will get through this though. Thanks Dahlia for raising this important point.
I’ve seen footage of Palestinian mothers praising that their suicidal children who have become martyrs by murdering jews. So these young children hear this verbiage from a young age. They internalize and substitute the bond to mother (who’s willing to let her children die) to Jews, a perversion. This is an interesting insight but I don’t see how to deter this. This is part and parcel the Palestinians indoctrination.