Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lynette Chazan's avatar

Dear Nancy, I am so happy to have found you and am so happy to know your group exists. I am a psychoanalytic psychotherapist in Australia, writing and talking about the antisemitism and antizionism around me, and have been dismayed by the political takeover of the psychoanalytic literature. and the marginalization of Jewish voices (which duplicates that in the arts and the left) seemingly almost without opposition and asking myself what it means. I do have an anecdote from here about the Jungians (I am not one). Their group is the only one I know of that has actually welcomed two senior Jewish members to present their story - even though it was greeted with virtual silence. Their interpretation of the silence is that it was politely hiding the conviction that they were apologists for genocide. They wished it would have been expressed. I wonder whether Jung's backstory has been sufficiently integrated (they seemed to think so) so as to create some kind of caution or brakes - that allowed the presentation to go ahead - on the the political takeover. Dr Lynette Chazan

Ready for more?