Last week I wrote about Ilhan Omar and the herd. Since then the New York Post has reported, citing unnamed sources, that federal investigators have obtained DNA evidence in the long-running question of whether she married her brother. What the evidence shows has not been made public, no charges have been filed, and she denies the allegation. The courts will decide the facts. What I want to examine is the world in which such a question can arise at all.
What I call the reverse world takes its name from the prophet Isaiah: “Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!” (Isaiah 5:20). Isaiah is not describing a liar who knows the truth and hides it. He is describing a world in which the moral compass itself has been turned upside down, so that the inversion feels natural, even righteous. In the reverse world, the person who asks a question is the aggressor, the one who must answer it is the victim, and the law that protects the individual is recast as persecution of the group.
Psychoanalytically, the reverse world rests on splitting and projection. What is bad inside cannot be tolerated, so it is expelled and lodged in someone else. The disgust that belongs to the act is placed on the person who names it. The shame that belongs to the family is placed on the investigator. A mind that never separated from the group cannot hold its own badness, because there is no individual self to hold it, so the bad must always be out there. That is why, in the reverse world, accountability is experienced not as justice but as an attack.
In a mind that has separated from the group, certain facts belong to the self: my birth date, my name, my father, my husband. They anchor identity, and they cannot be traded. In the reverse world, these facts become the property of the collective, adjusted whenever the family needs them. We can see the pattern in the documented record, before any DNA: a birth year that shifted, a father reportedly known by more than one name, and an “educator” who was in fact a colonel in Siad Barre’s army. Identity becomes a family document, and the family revises it. Prosecutors are now reportedly considering naming her late father as an unindicted co-conspirator. Even the case against her is being built around the family as a single unit.
Marriage is where this becomes most striking. Since Freud’s Totem and Taboo, psychoanalysis has understood the incest prohibition as the founding law of culture. It pushes the child out of the family and into the wider world, which makes marriage the decisive act of separation. If the allegation holds, the reverse world would have turned this law inside out. The institution meant to carry a person out of the clan would have been used to keep a member inside it, and America’s law would have been made to serve the herd. The prohibition would no longer be a boundary. It would be a tool.
Then there is Omar’s response. She calls the question disgusting. In that word, the disgust that would belong to the act, if it occurred, is relocated onto the person who asks. That is the reverse world in miniature: the questioner becomes the violator, and the clan becomes the victim.
In her first interview since the search, she went further. “It would be a huge undertaking to, I suppose, indict a 12-year-old for so cleverly conspiring to defraud immigration services,” she told MS NOW. But no one is investigating a 12-year-old. She arrived at twelve; the question is how old she was in 2000, when she became a citizen, and what she has signed as an adult since. Asked to answer as an adult, she answers as the child. Psychoanalytically, this is regression: the self that should stand accountable steps back into the place of the dependent child, inside the family, where responsibility belongs to the parents. The child cannot be blamed. The adult can be asked, and the adult has chosen to be the child.
Meanwhile, on October 26, Omar is scheduled to share a Minneapolis stage with the streamer Hasan Piker, who once said America deserved 9/11. Their host, state Sen. Omar Fateh, introduced them as “my sis” and “my brother,” champions for “our people.” In the reverse world, allies become kin, and the herd names itself.
Isaiah’s warning was addressed to a whole people, not to one person. The danger is not one congresswoman. It is a public culture that has learned to hear every request for accountability as an act of hatred. A self that has separated can say: this is mine, and I will answer for it. The herd can only say: they are attacking us.
Sources
Isaiah 5:20 (King James Version).
Sigmund Freud, Totem and Taboo (1913).
New York Post, reporting on DNA evidence in the Omar investigation, as summarized by VINnews, “Report: Feds Have DNA Evidence in Investigation of Ilhan Omar,” October 19, 2026. https://vinnews.com
Associated Press/Washington Post, “Federal probe of Rep. Ilhan Omar focuses on birth date and citizenship papers, people familiar say,” October 13, 2026. https://www.adn.com/nation-world/2026/10/13/federal-probe-of-rep-ilhan-omar-focuses-on-birth-date-and-citizenship-papers-people-familiar-say/
Just the News, “Dem Rep. Ilhan Omar’s team got birthdate changed in public records after she was elected to House.” https://justthenews.com/government/congress/dem-rep-ilhan-omars-team-got-birthdate-changed-public-records-after-she-was
Sahan Journal, “’He was loved by everyone’: The Somali community remembers Nur Omar Mohamed, who died of COVID-19,” June 2020. https://sahanjournal.com/remembering-minnesotans-lost-to-covid-19/he-was-loved-by-everyone-the-somali-community-remembers-nur-omar-mohamed-who-died-of-covid-19/
New York Post, on prosecutors’ conspiracy theory and Omar’s late father as possible unindicted co-conspirator, as summarized by the Huckabee Post, October 20, 2026. https://huckabeepost.substack.com
Associated Press, “Rep. Ilhan Omar Says She Will Move Out of Her Washington, DC, Home After Federal Search” (interview with MS NOW), via VINnews, October 22, 2026. https://vinnews.com
Jewish Insider, “Hasan Piker event in Minnesota with Ilhan Omar faces growing backlash,” October 2026. https://jewishinsider.com/2026/10/hasan-piker-event-ilhan-omar-growing-backlash/
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



