Leaders of the violent mob — Mamdani, El-Sayed and Omar — engage in the vicious verbal sleight of hand: taking a fair question that exposes them as public figures dangerously close to bending the truth, if not lying. They deploy a repertoire of destructive ways to avoid answering it, and every move in it has the same aim: deflect by answering back to the questioner or interviewer.
A question is not an accusation. Voters, prosecutors and rivals are entitled to ask, and the questions can be answered. A person who is exposed hears a fair question as an accusation, and answers the accusation instead.
Three scenes from the past two weeks show three different moves.
Ilhan Omar is asked about her name. A federal filing uses the name “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi.” Answering Trump on X, she writes: “My name has always been Ilhan Omar. Maybe you should focus on what your VP’s real name is.” This is tu quoque, the “you do it too” response. The question about her name goes unanswered, and a question about Vance’s name goes back across the table.
Abdul El-Sayed is asked at the final Michigan Senate debate about a 2012 letter to Egyptian President Morsi, which his opponent Mike Rogers says he signed. He calls the question “really quite shameful.” The asker is made to feel wrong for asking. On the Muslim Brotherhood link he tells the room he has never been part of it: “my mom, who’s a nurse in Missouri, it doesn’t make any sense.” The question is declared nonsense. This is the move gaslighting names, where the person asking is told that what they are asking about is not real.
Zohran Mamdani’s October 7 statement condemns Hamas in its opening lines, then viciously turns on Israel and calls the war in Gaza a genocide. The ADL’s Jonathan Greenblatt noted it never mentions Jews, the people murdered that day for being Jews. The victims are erased. The Conference of Presidents said he was “exploiting a day of profound grief to accuse Israel of genocide.” At his press conference he handed the charge back in the same shape: the day, he said, was used “as a justification for an ongoing genocide.” The accusation of exploiting the day passes from him to the mourners. This is DARVO = deny, attack, reverse, victim, offender
Psychoanalytic Visual Intelligence helps us understand what is going on in this disorienting “debate” by not answering honestly. Seen with the naked eye, these are not debating tactics. They are primitive mental states in action: the missing lego blocks of a mind that never fully developed the capacity to think about what it feels. A primitive mental state is one in which the mind cannot bear to hold a painful truth about itself. It does not think the pain through. Before a feeling can be symbolized, it cannot be put into words, so it is put into someone else. It expels it. Like Teflon, nothing sticks to them and they deflect the question. Only the child in the emperor’s new clothes, who knows the truth, sees it. The badness is put into someone else, who is made all bad while the self is made all good. The link between a fact and its meaning is cut, and speech does the work that thinking should do. For a mind in this state, exposure is not embarrassment. It is felt as annihilation, and it has to be got rid of at once. These are the states of a mind that never separated from its mother.
Think of the mind as being composed of lego blocks, being built during the maternal attachment when it is incubated in its jihadi shame honor culture’s terrors. Some of the lego blocks are missing but to the naked eye who does not have an understanding of shame honor cultures the nefarious leaders appear as normal but they are not normal because they are vicious in their attacking. With no separate self to hold responsibility, the badness has nowhere to go but outward, and someone else has to carry it.
That is what each scene shows. Omar’s tu quoque expels the problem of the name and relocates it in Vance. El-Sayed expels shame into the asker, then cuts the link the question made between the Morsi letter, his family and himself by calling the link nonsense — gaslighting at its best. Mamdani expels the charge of exploiting the day and puts it on the mourners i.e. DARVO.
It is a verbal sleight of hand, and it fails each time. A magician’s hand moves where the eye is looking. Here the sentence moves away from where the question was, and the question stays standing, because nothing has answered it. The maneuver then adds a second fact: the person could not bear to be asked. That is what the reader sees. The evasion is the answer.
This describes conduct in a moment of exposure, not a diagnosis of three people.
The questions are still standing: the name on the filing, the letter to Morsi, the day of mourning. Psychoanalytic Visual Intelligence trains the eye to stay on the question while the hand moves. We must be like the child in the emperor’s new clothes and not shy away from looking at what is in front of us, and wondering where the missing lego blocks are.
Sources:
El-Sayed at the Michigan Senate debate (Just the News): https://justthenews.com/politics-policy/elections/abdul-el-sayed-slams-rogers-over-muslim-brotherhood-accusations-during
Mamdani’s October 7 statement and the Jewish groups’ responses (Jewish Insider): https://jewishinsider.com/2026/10/mamdani-oct-7-statement-gaza-genocide-outrage-jewish-groups/
Mamdani defends his statement (Times of Israel): https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/mamdani-defends-oct-7-statement-that-infuriated-jewish-leaders-attendance-at-vigil/
Omar’s reply to Trump (VINnews): https://vinnews.com/2026/10/23/ilhan-omar-hits-back-at-trump-challenges-vance-over-his-name/
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



