Yesterday in the post Mamdani, El-Sayed and Omar: The Vicious Verbal Sleight of Hand — Primitive Mental States: When the Mind Cannot Symbolize, It Deflects
https://nancyharteveltkobrin.substack.com/p/mamdani-el-sayed-and-omar-the-vicious
I asked where their missing “thinking” blocks are? Here is the answer, and why it is so hard to deal with, in jihad BUT not impossible.
First a word about “primitive” in the phrase primitive mental states. Many say this is not a politically correct term. I beg to differ. It is an old term used after WWII by object relations such as Winnicott. We all have some primitive mental states, it depends to what extent, but the term describes well and sheds light on to a problem that is almost NEVER discussed when dealing with Islamists, jihadis and extremists.
In the first three years of life, a child lives in primitive mental states. Feelings are lived before they can be named, thought about, or placed in a separate self. A baby does not think, “I am ashamed.” Fear, comfort and withdrawal arrive through the mother’s face, voice, touch and mood. This is the maternal attachment, maternal dyad, the maternal matrix embedded within a culture. The mother is the baby’s first interpreter of their culture.
Over time her steady response helps the baby bear what is unbearable, and the blocks of a mind start to go into place: the capacity to wait, to feel guilt, to say “I did it,” to ask what a feeling means.
In a shame-honor culture especially where FGM is practiced and/or honor killing (FGM in Somalia; honor killing in Pakistan, Afghanistan, parts of Turkey and parts of the Arab world), the mother who lays these blocks is often mistreated and low in status herself. She must watch the family’s reputation, expect judgment and keep the peace.
Her anxiety is a sane response to real danger, but the baby takes it in as “terror,” as who is safe and who is not, as closeness that can be withdrawn —abandonment. The blocks for reflection and a separate self do not get built, because the one building them is barely allowed a self of her own. The baby also learns early who is on which side of the group line, long before s/he has words for it.
Why can we not see the missing blocks? Because nothing looks wrong. The surface is cool and polished just like the Islamist deadly trio--Mamdani-ElSayed-Omar. Underneath is what I call the volcanic iceberg. Nothing is visibly missing until a fair question exposes it. Then the mind that cannot hold a painful truth about itself throws it outward onto the questioner. Exposure is felt as annihilation, so the deflection is instant.
Why is this so hard in relation to jihad?
• First, the damage is preverbal. Argument and evidence cannot reach what was never put into words, i.e. symbolized.
• Second, in a culture where honor is everything, rage feels demanded by the situation, and violence is presented as cleansing, as if blood could wash away humiliation. In fact one must willfully spill blood to cleanse honor in war. The person turns outward to punish the source of shame instead of asking what the rage is defending.
• Third, whoever is exposed experiences the asking itself as an attack, so honest inquiry makes the evasion worse.
• Fourth, forgive me for saying because I wish so much that textbooks can “fix” this problem but we have to be honest with ourselves – it is like putting a bandaid on a raging traumatic wound of the mind. Textbooks arrive late. By the time a child meets one, the feelings are already familiar.
What must be done?
• Start where the blocks are laid: protect and raise the status of mothers, through legal protection, schooling for girls and early childhood support.
• Name the specific norms that make domination look virtuous and violence look like repair, and hold perpetrators fully responsible.
• Remove stereotypes from textbooks, and teach children that violence is a choice and not a way to restore honor.
• Boldly name the predator perpetrators: Aim all of this at the structure and the perpetrators, never at an entire people. And we must train the eye to stay on the question while the hand moves.
• State unequivocally to all the leaders of these countries and regions – this is your cultural problem that has been forced on us and we do not want it. Your problem has become our problem and we set limits and will not accept it.
Two cautions. Research shows that babies begin to notice differences between people in the first year of life, and that what they learn to make of those differences depends on the world around them. It does not show that babies hate, or that one path leads from the cradle to jihad. And this describes conduct under exposure, not a diagnosis of anyone.
Sources:
Children’s racial categorization in context: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4836385/
Development of social categories and language: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7577394/
UN handbook on reporting violence against women and girls: https://www.un.org/sexualviolenceinconflict/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/report/reporting-on-violence-against-women-and-girls-a-handbook-for-journalists/371524eng.pdf
UK Parliament report on so-called honor-based abuse: https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm5803/cmselect/cmwomeq/831/report.html
UNFPA, Gender Justice and Law in the Arab States region: https://arabstates.unfpa.org/en/publications/gender-justice-and-law-arab-states-region
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y




Beautiful analysis. Sadly, its wasted on the incomprehending and empathically attenuated personalities that youre referring to. The best course.of treatment to resove this deep underlying neurosis is aggressive psychotherapy in the form of 2 hollow point 9mm parrabellum rounds inserted rapidly... at an approximate.velocity of 2000 miles per hour into the subjects prefrontal cortex.
Im just saying.
🤔
Leaders are representative of the culture and will be hard pressed to try and change the culture of the majority.