On the third anniversary of October 7th, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani issued a statement. It began correctly. He named Hamas, he named its war crimes, and he offered a sentence of grief for the friends and neighbors who still carry the loss.
Then he turned. “The suffering did not begin nor end that day,” he wrote, and the rest of the statement, more than twice the length of what came before, was an indictment of Israel: genocide, occupation, apartheid, American tax dollars, arms shipments. By the end, the day of the massacre had become a day of accusation against the people who were massacred.
As a psychoanalyst who has spent decades studying the minds of perpetrators and those who sympathize with them, I want to look at the structure of this statement rather than its slogans. The structure says more.
The first thing to notice is how short the grief is. Mourning requires the capacity to stay with another person’s pain without needing to change the subject. The mayor could not stay. One sentence of sorrow was all he could manage before he had to get away from it. When grief for Jews becomes intolerable to someone, it is usually because it threatens a story he needs to believe, in which Jews are never the victims.
The second thing to notice is what is missing. As the ADL’s Jonathan Greenblatt pointed out, the word “Jews” does not appear. The victims of the worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust are mourned without being named as Jews. This is not an oversight. To name them would be to admit why they were killed. Hamas did not murder 1,200 people and drag 251 into Gaza because of a policy dispute. It did so because they were Jews. Erasing the word erases the motive, and erasing the motive clears the way for the reversal that follows.
The third thing is that reversal itself. In the mayor’s statement, the victim becomes the perpetrator within a few lines. This is projection in its plainest form. The intolerable thing, the wish to annihilate, is lifted off the actual killers and placed onto those who defended themselves. Once that move is made, the anniversary no longer belongs to the dead. It belongs to the accuser.
That is what I mean by mourning taken from the mourners. Jewish New Yorkers asked for one day. Not agreement with Israeli policy, not silence on Gaza, just one day on which their dead could be their dead. The mayor of the city with the largest Jewish population outside Israel could not give them that.
This matters beyond hurt feelings. A mayor’s words set the emotional temperature of a city. When the most powerful official in New York tells his constituents, on the anniversary of a pogrom, that the real crime is the Jewish state’s existence and defense, he is giving permission. Those who already hate hear that their hatred is righteous. The rise in attacks on Jews in New York did not happen in a vacuum.
I have written before about how “Israeli” has become the new code word for “Jew.” The October 7th statement shows the same mechanism working from the other direction. Here, the Jew disappears altogether, and only the Israeli, recast as the criminal, remains.
What can be done? Not more outrage. Outrage is what a provocateur wants. Every condemnation confirms that he holds the power to wound, and he pays nothing for it. Anyone who has worked with someone who tests limits knows you do not contain that person by shouting. You set a calm, consistent boundary and attach a consequence to it.
The boundary should be this: Jewish institutions in New York, including the federations, the synagogues, the major agencies and Jewish elected officials, should agree together that the mayor will not be invited to Jewish community events, will not be given photo opportunities, and will not speak from Jewish platforms. This holds until he meets one public condition: he must name the victims of October 7th as Jews and acknowledge that they were murdered because they were Jews. The condition is stated once and is not negotiated. Mamdani needs the image of Jewish acceptance in order to claim he is not hostile to Jews. The community can stop providing it.
Two further steps give the boundary weight. First, the community should hold its own civic October 7th memorial, with the Governor, Council members and non-Jewish allies standing beside it, so that the city’s memory of that day no longer belongs to the mayor. Second, every antisemitic incident in New York and the city’s response to it should be documented and sent each month to the City Council, to Albany and to the Justice Department. Outrage fades. A record does not.
One sentence of grief followed by a long accusation is not mourning. It is the appropriation of mourning. Jewish New Yorkers do not need to argue with it. They need to stop lending it their presence.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



I will try. I also asked the JPost to republish in a revised form and am waiting to hear. Will do and great idea. Thanks.
Can you send this to city council? To Jessica Tisch?