Like her husband Zohran, Rama Duwaji is a provocateur. The Egyptians have a phrase for such a pair: zay el-fula w’itqasamet nossein, like a fava bean split into two halves. Two peas in a pod. In April 2024, before she became the first lady of New York City, she posted a video of herself animating a portrait of the Palestinian painter Sliman Mansour. She introduced herself as a Syrian illustrator in Brooklyn and called Mansour an artist of the Intifada who had “inspired the work that I do.” She spoke of his two jail terms with pride. Mansour died in Jerusalem on August 24th, at the age of 79.
This week The Washington Free Beacon went through the public record of the man Duwaji chose as her model. By its account, Mansour called the founders of Hamas great heroes. On October 8th, while Israeli families were still searching for their dead, he posted his painting of a fighter clutching a gun. In 2015 he praised Hitler as a capable painter. In 2016 he shared the claim that the diary of Anne Frank was a forgery written by an American Jew. In 2021 Yahya Sinwar stood before a banner reworked from Mansour’s most famous painting and thanked Iran for its money and weapons. Mansour said it did not bother him at all.
Read that list again. Every item turns reality inside out. The men who murder Jews are heroes. The murdered Jewish girl is a liar. Hitler is an artist. A jail term is a medal. This is the reverse psychotic world, where good is bad and bad is good. It is not exaggeration or rhetoric. It is how the impaired mind is organized when it has never learned to hold good and bad together in one person, beginning with the first person, the mother. The infant who cannot bear that the same mother both feeds and frustrates splits her in two: an all-good mother to worship and an all-bad mother to destroy. When that split is never mended, the grown person lives inside it. The good must be placed somewhere, so the killer becomes the hero. The bad must be placed somewhere, so the Jew becomes the oppressor, and his murdered child becomes a forger. Such a person never knows the middle ground, the grey. Everything is black or white, shaming and blaming.
This is paranoia, and we must name it. Melanie Klein called the infant’s split world the paranoid-schizoid position: the good is idealized, the bad is cast out and then feared as a persecutor. We often forget, or minimize, that paranoia at its extreme is a psychosis, one filled with rage, aggression and hatred. The paranoid mind is certain it is being persecuted, so it persecutes first and calls it self-defense. I am not diagnosing Rama Duwaji. I am reading the world her model painted and the world she chose to admire. It behooves us to call a spade a spade: that world is paranoid.
A portrait is not a tweet. A tweet takes seconds. A portrait takes hours of looking. The artist studies a face, line by line, until she has taken it inside and can give it back. This is what I call Psychoanalytic Visual Intelligence: attending to what a person shows us without knowing she is showing it. Duwaji says little in public. Her husband calls her a private person. Yet she has told us a great deal with her brush. She seems to believe she can get away with it by saying nothing and hiding behind her art, passing it off as only a picture.
The word intifada comes to mind as it comes from the Arabic root for shaking off, the way a dog shakes water from its back. Mansour was an artist of the Intifada, and his admirer has learned the same motion: shake it off, and nothing sticks. Or does it? To the psychoanalytic visual eye, the truth prevails. She chose an older man, a father figure, and gazed at him with admiration. She inhabits the reverse world and finds it beautiful. That is identification, and it is a choice.
Consider the diary. Anne Frank was a girl in hiding who wrote to an imaginary friend because she had no one else to tell. After the Nazis murdered her, her words were all that remained of her. To call the diary a forgery is to kill her a second time, by taking away the one thing she left behind, her voice. In the reverse world the victim is the liar and the liar is the witness. Duwaji is a young woman artist. Her model denied a murdered Jewish girl her own words. We do not know whether Duwaji read those posts. We do know whose face she chose to study, and for how long.
Then there is the painting Sinwar borrowed. Mansour’s Camel of Hardship, from 1973, shows an old porter bent under the weight of Jerusalem, holding the city on his back the way a mother holds an infant. The bond is a burden, but it is still a bond. In Sinwar’s banner, the old man becomes a young fighter. The weight of the city transforms into the weapon. Mansour approved. In the reverse world even love of a city turns into a call to kill. The holding of the first bond becomes armed hatred, the psychic prosthesis that replaces the self that never gained a conscience.
Duwaji painted Mansour beneath a banner accusing the Jewish state of apartheid. The people who were gassed become the oppressors, and the people who celebrate their murder become the oppressed. She was born in Houston, yet she presents herself as Syrian, and then as a daughter of Palestine, each step taking her further from where she was born and closer to a grievance she inherited. Her husband now governs the largest Jewish city outside Israel. She has served dinner at Gracie Mansion to Mahmoud Khalil, a leader of the anti-Israel protests at Columbia. Last week came the olive oil brand that sells a bottle honoring a man who shot down a plane. In the reverse world, killing is heritage and heritage is sold by the bottle.
The mayor asks us to see his wife as a private artist. Very well. Let us look at her art. A portrait is a love letter written with a brush. Rama Duwaji wrote hers to a man who mocked a murdered Jewish girl and cheered the men who murder Jews today. In the reverse world, that is called inspiration. In ours, it is blatant antisemitism. New Yorkers should not let the reverse world take up residence in Gracie Mansion.
What We Must Do
Outrage is not enough. Each new revelation brings a day of anger, and then the first lady shakes it off, like the dog shaking off the water. We need to set limits instead, and to set them creatively.
First, name it. When a public figure admires a man who called Anne Frank’s diary a forgery, the word is antisemitism, not activism and not art. Editors, rabbis, council members and ordinary New Yorkers should say the word out loud and refuse the softer ones.
Second, ask the mayor. Reporters at City Hall should put one question to Zohran Mamdani: does he share his wife’s admiration for Sliman Mansour, yes or no? A private person may keep her silence. The mayor of the largest Jewish community outside Israel may not. And his answer must contain the word Jew. Not “Israeli,” not “Zionist,” not “community.” Anne Frank was not murdered as a Zionist. She was murdered as a Jew. A mayor who cannot say the word cannot protect the people it names. He must also acknowledge what the word means. Jew comes from the Hebrew Yehudi, a person of Judah, the land the Romans called Judea. The name itself ties the people to the land. That is why the reverse world cannot bear to say it.
Third, answer the forgery with the diary. Let New Yorkers gather in City Hall Park and read Anne Frank’s diary aloud, page by page, in the voice the reverse world tried to take from her. Let schools and libraries do the same. Nothing restores a stolen voice like hearing it.
Fourth, train the eye. Antisemitism no longer needs words. It travels in portraits, banners and olive oil bottles, and it hides behind the claim that it is only art. Teachers, journalists and security professionals must learn to read images the way they read text. That is the work of Psychoanalytic Visual Intelligence. To the psychoanalytic visual eye, the truth prevails, but only if we keep looking.
Sources
Jon Levine, “NYC First Lady Painted Portrait of Her ‘Inspiration’: A Jew-Hating Artist Who Said ‘Anne Frank’ Is a Hoax, Posted Hitler’s Paintings, and Celebrated Oct 7,” The Washington Free Beacon, October 13, 2026. https://freebeacon.substack.com/p/nyc-first-lady-painted-portrait-of
“Sliman Mansour, Painter of Palestinian Hope and Humanity, Dies at 79,” Hyperallergic, August 2026. https://hyperallergic.com/sliman-mansour-painter-of-palestinian-hope-and-humanity-dies-at-79/
“Palestinian Artist Sliman Mansour Dies at 79 in Jerusalem,” Ground News, August 2026. https://ground.news/article/palestinian-artist-sliman-mansour-dies-aged-79
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



A fava bean split in two halves?
More like two butt cheeks around a dirty Hamasshole.