On October 17, more than half a million French people marched over prices, fuel and failing services. By evening, fringes had set a town hall on fire, looted shops and broken into the prefect’s residence in Bordeaux. Nearly 1,800 were arrested and more than 500 officers were hurt. Then came the picture that went round the world: a Palestinian flag on the statue of the Republic, and flags in the marches in Marseille and Lyon.
On the Thai island of Phuket, demonstrators are due to gather near the Chabad House in Patong from 4 p.m. to 10 p.m. The organizers, including the Phuket Land Protection Group, accuse Israeli-linked businesses and Chabad of illicit activities and powerful vested interests. Provincial authorities have found no evidence for the claims. In September about 500 Thais gathered near the same building holding signs reading “SAVE PHUKET NO ISRAEL” and chanting “Free Palestine.”
The two places have nothing in common except the psychology. In France the grievance is the price of bread. In Phuket it is land, and the fear that foreigners are taking the island. Both are ordinary local complaints, and neither has anything to do with Gaza. Yet in both places the crowd found the same costume.
This is global identification, and it is primitive. A Frenchman angry about fuel and a Thai angry about property each take on the identity of the most photographed victim on earth. In The Jihadi Dictionary I call these copy-cat identifications: borrowed, not earned. Having put on the victim’s costume, the crowd feels entitled to act as a perpetrator.
The mob does the rest. Inside a crowd there is no individual self, only the group, which fuses its members into a herd, and judgment is lost with it. Feeling spreads by sight, like a contagion. Nobody in the mob decides to burn the town hall or to march on a synagogue. The mob does it, and every member feels carried along and innocent.
Then the mob stages itself. Every grievance wants a stage, and the stage is the camera. The burning town hall, the flag on the statue and the signs outside the Chabad House are props in a performance written for the phone in the next hand. Mass and social media are the megaphone and the echo chamber of validation. Paris performs for Rome, Rome for Brussels, and Brussels for Patong. The circuit completes itself.
Look at where the performance lands. A rage about prices in France ends with a flag on Marianne, the mother of the nation, who is accused of failing to feed her children. A rage about land in Phuket ends at a Jewish house of prayer, whose people are accused of taking the island. Greed prevails and the attack on Israel and Jews reveals the psychotic crowd’s envy. In both places the grievance is real and small, and the target is large and symbolic. The words “Israeli-linked” turn a local religious house into a state, and the state into an enemy. A Chabad rabbi in Patong is not the Israeli government. The mob does not need him to be anything else, because the flag has already done its work.
Investigators found no evidence for the accusations in Phuket, and the reports from France describe cost-of-living protests whose violence came from fringes, not from the marchers as a whole. The flag shows what the crowd picked up to make its rage look like justice, and it does not show who started the violence. This theater of terrorism provides a space in which the psychotic can dance in the circus, thereby preserving the Big Lie that Israel is committing genocide. We do not have to dance in the Palestinian psychotic circus.
What can be done? The flag cannot be removed, and banning it would hand the crowd a confrontation, a martyr and a better picture. The answer is to take away the license it gives. Prosecute the acts in full, the arson, the looting, the assault and the harassment outside a Chabad House, and treat the flag as neither an excuse nor an aggravation, so that the crime is judged and the costume ignored. The man who burns a town hall under a flag is judged as exactly what he is. Once the costume excuses nothing, it loses most of its appeal. Then answer the local grievance directly and early. If the complaint is prices or land, officials should address prices and land, and say publicly that the accusations against Chabad have no evidence behind them. A crowd with a real complaint answered does not need a borrowed victim. Finally, name the displacement out loud, again and again: your anger is about your own life, and this flag is a costume. This is where Psychoanalytic Visual Intelligence earns its place, because it teaches us to read what the mob picks up before we argue about the cause it claims.
The next riot, in Paris, Phuket or Detroit, will use the same flag, the same cameras and the same theater. We should be ready for it and not give it a platform, by acting swiftly and preemptively.
On October 31, police in London warned of arrests and issued a dispersal order ahead of a protest outside the US embassy, which shows the preemptive action I describe, though arrests for expressing support differ from prosecuting the acts themselves, and the cameras will decide which picture the world sees.
Sources:
https://www.omanobserver.om/article/1197997/world/europe/france-counts-cost-of-worst-unrest
https://euroweeklynews.com/2026/10/17/palestinian-flag-flies-on-paris-republic-statue-as-unrest-hits-france-italy-and-belgium-could-spain-be-next/
https://www.i24news.tv/fr/actu/france/artc-manifestations-du-17-octobre-violences-a-marseille-et-lyon-des-drapeaux-palestiniens-dans-les-corteges
https://www.aljazeera.com/gallery/2026/10/18/photos-protests-across-france-spiral-into-looting-blazes-and-clashes
https://aseannow.com/thailand-news/phuket-activists-set-october-31-chabad-house-protest-r4428/
https://www.algemeiner.com/2026/09/15/thailand-authorities-order-sweeping-investigation-chabad-compound-rosh-hashanah-event-canceled
https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/uk-police-warn-of-arrests-ahead-of-pro-palestinian-protest-outside-us-embassy/
Kobrin, N. H. The Jihadi Dictionary (2016): entries on Mass Contagion, Media (Mass and Social), Group Self.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



