When Mark Levine ran for New York City comptroller, he promised to restore the city’s investment in Israel Bonds. His predecessor, Brad Lander, had let those holdings lapse. Levine called the bonds “a long-term safe and secure investment” and said he would bring them back.
This week he told the New York Times he would not. He said he was “heartbroken at the state of politics,” pointed to instability in the region and his office’s preference for shorter-term bonds, and paired the decision with criticism of Prime Minister Netanyahu. Mayor Zohran Mamdani welcomed it the same day: “I don’t believe that our city should purchase Israel bonds.”
The finances do not explain the decision. Israel has made every payment of principal and interest on its bonds, on time, since 1951, including every payment owed to New York’s pension funds over nearly fifty years. The same funds, which manage about $330 billion for the city’s teachers, firefighters, police officers and other workers, hold investments in China, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Qatar and other non-democratic regimes, Qatar among them the patron of Hamas’s leadership, whose stability nobody questions in public. Only one country was singled out for risk, and it was the Jewish state.
As a psychoanalyst who studies perpetrators and predators and the people around them, I am less interested in Levine’s stated reasons than in the movement of the decision itself. Mamdani did not have to order anything. A man who had promised the opposite came to the mayor’s position on his own and then described it as his own judgment.
Anna Freud called this identification with the aggressor. Under pressure, a person adopts the position of the one who threatens him, because standing beside the threat feels safer than standing in front of it. Levine was targeted in March by a “Break the Bonds” rally outside his office. Seven months later, he speaks the protesters’ language and calls it heartbreak.
This is how a provocateur’s influence travels. It does not depend on the provocateur acting. It depends on others anticipating him and accommodating him before he asks. Each accommodation then becomes evidence that the position was reasonable all along. When the limit is not held at the top, it erodes everywhere beneath it, one quiet accommodation at a time.
A provocateur is not a narcissist. He is something worse, more violent and more nefarious. Provocateurs are fundamentally predators. Those around him accommodate him because they are fundamentally terrified of him. Their unspoken thought is “There but for the grace of God go I.” So they cut off a finger to feed the monster, hoping it will be satisfied. It never is.
What We Must Do
Outrage at Levine will not work. He has already shown how he responds to pressure, and angry pressure from one side will only confirm his sense that he is caught between two mobs. The response has to be calm, specific and come from those with standing.
Pension Fund Holders Must Speak Out
First, the people the money belongs to should speak. The pension funds belong to teachers, firefighters, police officers and city workers, and their union trustees sit on the boards. Members can ask their trustees, in writing and on the record, one plain question: why was Israel alone dropped for risk, when its repayment record is perfect and holdings in China and Qatar were kept?
Publish the Analysis
Second, Levine has said his office’s analysis is ongoing. The City Council should ask him to publish it. If the risk is real, it can be shown in numbers. If it cannot be shown, the public will see that the decision was political, not financial.
Gifting Israel Bonds: A Return to a Much-Cherished Practice
Third, the Jewish community can answer with confidence rather than complaint. Synagogues, federations and individuals can buy Israel Bonds themselves, publicly, and say why. A city official’s withdrawal of trust is best answered by others visibly extending it. For decades after Israel Bonds began in 1951, a bond tucked into an envelope was a familiar bar and bat mitzvah gift in American Jewish families. It is called an Israel Bond because it is issued by the State of Israel, but the word carries more. We are Jews, Yehudim, a people named for Judea, and this bond is our bond, our commitment to the Land of Israel, our maternal homeland. It is our maternal bond. This past May, I bought an Israel Bond for my grandson’s bar mitzvah. Now is the time for us to return to the practice of giving Israel Bonds as bar and bat mitzvah gifts.
Levine said he struggled with the decision personally. I believe him. People who identify with the aggressor usually do. The struggle is the sign that he knows what he is giving up.
We must refuse to dance in Mamdani’s circus.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y


