Chapter ten of Karen Elliott House’s The Man Who Would Be King is called “Pied Piper.” She writes that, “like a modern-day Pied Piper,” MBS offers “a new tune of nationalism” to lure the 65 percent of Saudis under thirty to follow him. The title fits the lure. The legend adds a warning. In Hamelin the town breaks its promise, and the piper leads the children away. In this chapter MBS is the one making the promise, and House ends by saying the next five years will show whether $1 trillion in gigaprojects produces jobs or “a host of white elephants.”
Walls and Paranoia
House opens with Bedouins “suspicious of anyone outside their own tribe,” living “clannish lives behind high walls.” She says the Al Saud built a maze to keep them isolated, so they “won’t coalesce around common frustrations.” In my Jihadi Dictionary, the entry on asabiyah gives the Arabic root as ayn-sad-ba, “to bind,” and I write that in a shame-honor culture the group self predominates over the individual. The group is fused, and fusion yields group-think and paranoia. In the pages I read, House never mentions shame-honor. She cites Ibn Khaldun, who held that asabiyyah dissipates over four generations, and presents MBS’s revival of it as pride. I read it as the revival of fusion, a regressed group self. A people who feel under attack from every outsider are living in persecutory anxiety, and nationalism gives that anxiety a bigger tribe to belong to.
Wedding Washing
We have sportswashing. King Abdul Aziz practiced wedding washing. To dissolve tribal divisions as that was his intention but I wax analytic and wonder what was his fantasy? He married hundreds of tribal women, many of them widows of chiefs he had conquered, often for one night. By his own count he had consummated marriages with 135 virgins and about 100 other women by 1930, and by his death the total was about 275. Bragging rights. Divorce was a man saying three times — “I divorce you”; the woman had no choice. The message to the tribes was that we are all kin. A woman married for one night is an object, not a constant person. Where women are objectified, so are the baby and the men who must follow. Yet House writes: “tribal segmentation remains to this day.” So the royal wedding washing laundry didn’t turn out clean. Some 80 percent of Saudis say they identify with a tribe, and about three thousand chiefs are paid by the government. The weddings changed the family tree. They did not change the nursery, and the early child-rearing practices stay the same.
The Father’s Sand
MBS told Jared Kushner: “My father’s generation came to Riyadh when it was just sand.” I wonder if Jared answered that Tel Aviv was sand too. House comments: “Classic MBS. To him the glass is only 10 percent full but he will fill the rest.” I just associated that if you dropped the M then what do you have — BS. This is Klein’s manic defense again: contempt for the previous generation, and triumph over it. The generation he scorns includes his father, King Salman, who told House that “Saudi Arabia was many kingdoms. Every tribe was a kingdom... If you take away Islam, our country will be dismantled.” The father warns, and the son says poof. By royal decree in 2022 the founding day became February 22, 1727, and the covenant with ibn Abd al-Wahhab was written out of the founding story. House compares this to erasing George Washington from America.
The Vest and the Gym Shoes
At the Formula E races in 2019 MBS wore a Barbour jacket over his thobe, Tom Ford aviators and black Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 trainers, and hundreds of Saudis shared their receipts for the jacket. At Somewhere, the new restaurant in Al Ula, he wore a Brunello Cucinelli vest that sells for $6,900. House says he expects young Saudis to pledge “unquestioned loyalty to him.” Meanwhile a 2024 ruling requires Saudis who work for the government to wear formal Saudi attire at all times, and men may not remove their head coverings. The piper dresses as he likes, and his followers dress by rule or by receipt. This is the false self as fashion: the look is copied, and the inside is not asked about. In Diriyah the government even pays young men to dress like King Abdul Aziz and greet tourists “just as cartoon characters greet visitors to Disney World.”
Jews and the Concubine
House reports that Mohammed al-Essa, MBS’s chief adviser on Islam, signed a memorandum with the American Jewish Committee and visited Auschwitz. So the gesture toward Jews comes through an intermediary, not from MBS himself. On August 7 MBS signed the Mecca Joint Deterrence Agreement with Turkey and Pakistan, under which an attack on one is an attack on all. A Turkish official said it is not aimed at any actor, but the three are concerned about Israel’s growing influence. To me, Israel is the concubine: wanted privately, not acknowledged in public. The Prophet Muhammad’s three favorite concubines were two Jewish women and one Christian and so the unconsciously imprinted pattern goes on. My first book The Banality of Suicide Terrorism: The Naked Truth about the Psychology of Islamic Suicide Bombing is also dedicated to these women. I wonder what Jared Kushner and MBS said to each other about Judaism. The book gives only the sand.
Somewhere
The restaurant is called Somewhere. Where is he now? The Wall Street Journal reportedly wrote in October that MBS moves between fortified palaces with bunkers after Houthi missile strikes on Riyadh, and that his last public appearance was October 6. The details have not been independently established. On November 8 shrapnel from an attempted attack damaged an Aramco building in Riyadh. House says that without religion as a “buffer of blame,” MBS is now accountable for success or failure. This is too much too fast, and the legend says what happens when the promise is broken: the piper leads the children away, and the parents are left behind.
Sources:
Karen Elliott House, The Man Who Would Be King (Harper, 2025), Chapter Ten, “Pied Piper.”
Kobrin, N. H. (2016). The Jihadi Dictionary, entry “Asabiyah,” pp. 25-26. Multieducator Press.
Al Jazeera, “Turkiye, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan sign joint defence agreement: What’s in it?”, August 7, 2026: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/8/7/turkiye-saudi-arabi-pakistan-sign-joint-defence-agreement-whats-in-it
Al Jazeera, “Saudi Aramco building in Riyadh damaged in ‘attempted’ attack,” November 8, 2026: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/8/saudi-arabia-intercepts-houthi-missiles-targeting-riyadh-eastern-province
Daily Pakistan, October 12, 2026, citing the Wall Street Journal: https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/12-Oct-2026/saudi-crown-prince-mbs-hiding-in-bunkers-amid-houthi-missile-attacks-wsj-report-says
Sahara Reporters, October 12, 2026: https://saharareporters.com/2026/10/12/saudi-crown-prince-moves-between-palaces-equipped-bunkers-amid-houthi-missile-attacks
Klein, M. (1935). A contribution to the psychogenesis of manic-depressive states.
Winnicott, D. W. (1960). Ego distortion in terms of true and false self.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



