Chapter Eight of Karen Elliott House’s The Man Who Would Be King, “The Sports of Kings,” opens in a Riyadh arena. Twenty-six thousand mostly Saudi fans watch Tyson Fury fight Francis Ngannou in the “Battle of the Baddest.” A risqué dance performance is seemingly intended to show that religious restrictions are a thing of the past. The squeals are loudest for Kanye West and Eminem. House concludes: “This is definitely not your father’s Saudi Arabia.”
The Boxing Ring: A Stage Set for the World
The fight is not for the fighters. It is an announcement. The point of the evening is the audience’s reaction: look at us, we are alive. Mike Tyson was paid to promote it, and Ronaldo sits ringside. This is a country that wants to be seen being enlivened.
Kanye West now legally goes by Ye. After a run of antisemitic statements, including praise of Hitler, he apologized in a Wall Street Journal ad in January 2026 and blamed bipolar disorder and a brain injury. A kingdom that wants to be seen as moderate chose, for its night of liberation, a headliner whose record on Jews is public.
Sportswashing and Academic Washing
MBS told Fox: “If sportswashing is going to increase my GDP by 1 percent, then we’ll continue doing sportswashing.” The admission is disarming, and it is a defense in its own right. Name the accusation first and the accusation loses its sting.
The term made me think of academic washing. In the 1970s it was known that those who would become involved in identity politics would make big money teaching in KSA. It was a known phenomenon. A 1979 letter to The New York Review of Books, written from Riyadh by a foreign academic, describes the University of Riyadh recruiting Western faculty through ads in that very Review, the pay good and the passports held by the university. Just buy it and them. It misses the point. Buying the stars and buying the scholars share one premise: that prestige can be bought and that the buyer will inherit it. What is bought is the performance of vitality, not vitality itself.
And what about education? In the pages I have read, education gets no chapter of its own, while sport gets an entire chapter. That is odd. A vibrant community is built from the inside, in schools, in curiosity, in the habit of effort. Stadiums can be built by contract. What does this teach the Saudi children? Academics seem low on the priority list. Don dinero habla: money talks, as Kasatkina says later in the chapter.
The Money: Buying Part Objects
Saudi Arabia spent $875 million in 2023 on soccer stars, more than any European nation except Britain. Ronaldo gets $200 million a year. Benzema got $112 million for each of two seasons, plus $20 million a year as an ambassador to help secure the 2034 World Cup. Mbappé was offered $1.1 billion and refused. Messi was offered $420 million, declined, and became a goodwill ambassador for the Ministry of Tourism at $25 million a year.
In Kleinian terms these are idealized part objects. The stars are not people the kingdom knows. They are glittering fragments acquired to fill an inner emptiness, and the manic defense lives on triumph, possession and contempt for the need behind them. The thing bought is the feeling of not being deprived.
Messi’s Clause: The False Self
Messi must not say anything that would “tarnish” the image of Saudi Arabia. House writes: “Some see this restriction as proof of sportswashing. It may be. But in reality, it is just another example of restriction on free speech that all Saudis endure under MBS.”
Analytically this is Winnicott’s false self (1960), made contractual. The star is hired to be compliant and radiant, and what he truly thinks is excluded from view. What happens to Messi is what the chapter shows happening to everyone: authenticity is the one thing that cannot be bought and must not be spoken.
A Nintendo at Age Six: Play
House writes that the prince “has long had an interest in gaming since he got his first Nintendo at age six. Now he’s trying to transform a childhood passion into a profitable new industry.” The Esports World Cup in Riyadh has a $60 million purse and drew one million visitors.
For Winnicott, play is what a child does in the space between self and world, held safely by a mother who is there. Here, the one remembered childhood pleasure is turned into an industry. It is poignant, and it fits the unseen years theme: the first six years of a first-born son who was his mother’s honor. I have written elsewhere about the missing mother and Neom as a bid for attunement. The Nintendo may be what a lonely boy had instead of someone to play with.
Prince Abdullah bin Musa’id says sports teach “self-sufficiency and striving for self-improvement,” and adds that Saudis “prefer not to work if they can avoid it... so they don’t train hard or try hard.” That reluctance to exert is, he says, now fading. Hear the same shame from earlier posts: a people told they cannot try, now being ordered to strive.
The Vibrant Society: Defense Against Deadness
Vision 2030’s three goals are a vibrant society, a thriving economy and an ambitious nation. Before the reforms, young men kicked a ball in garbage-strewn fields “or sit home,” and women were forbidden by the ulama to exercise on the claim that it would damage their reproductive ability. The body was the enemy and the home was a tomb.
André Green’s dead mother complex describes a child whose mother was present but emotionally absent. The child identifies with the deadness and grows up afraid of it, and so builds vivacity as a defense. The obsession with attracting people, with enlivening the population for the fantasy of a vibrant community, reads as exactly this. The society is not being invited to live. It is being ordered to prove it is not dead.
That is why the fans’ squeals matter more to the event than the fight. And it is why the women chanting “Let’s go Coco” at the WTA Finals in Riyadh are moving and unsettling at once. Their joy is real. It also serves a stage manager.
The key for a vibrant society would be a massive injection of money and educational programming for early childhood development, beginning at birth. In Israel we have Tipat Halav, “a drop of milk,” founded in Jerusalem in 1921. It began as milk and became a mother-and-baby clinic: checkups, vaccinations, guidance for new mothers, and screening for postpartum depression. Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Education sets a target to raise kindergarten enrollment from 17 percent to 90 percent by 2030, which begins at age three. I could not find a Saudi program that reaches mother and infant in the unseen years, from birth to age three. A kingdom that buys $875 million of soccer stars in a single year has not yet bought that.
The Cost of the Cure
Saudi Arabia is the only bidder for the 2034 World Cup. Human rights groups ask for the release of political prisoners, an independent judiciary, rights for the migrant workers who build the stadiums, and the criminalizing of marital rape. Nadal, the kingdom’s tennis ambassador, asks whether the alternative is “for them to continue being bad, continue keeping the country locked up with more inequality?” Navratilova and Evert called the WTA move “token measures,” and Kasatkina said: “Money talks in our world right now.”
House spends a whole chapter on this, and it is odd that she does. The chapter is entertaining and reads like a sports page. The harder question is left to the psychoanalyst: what is a man purchasing when he purchases a crowd?
An unmourned emptiness cannot be filled by a roaring stadium. It can only be drowned out for ninety minutes at a time.
Sources: Karen Elliott House, The Man Who Would Be King (Harper, 2025), Chapter Eight, “The Sports of Kings,” from p. 119; Kobrin, “Where is Mohammed bin Salman’s mother? And why does it matter for Israel?” The Jerusalem Post, Feb 2, 2026, https://www.jpost.com/opinion/article-885321; Name withheld, letter to the editor, The New York Review of Books, June 28, 1979, https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1979/06/28/the-saudi-way/; Ye (Kanye West) apology, NBC News, Jan 2026, https://www.nbcnews.com/pop-culture/music/ye-formerly-kanye-west-apologizes-reckless-antisemitic-comments-rcna255938; Saudi Ministry of Education, Kindergarten, https://moe.gov.sa/en/education/general-education/kindergarten; Saudi Ministry of Health, World Children’s Day, Nov 20, 2025, https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/MediaCenter/News/Pages/News-2025-11-20-002.aspx; Klein, “A Contribution to the Psychogenesis of Manic-Depressive States” (1935); Winnicott, “Ego Distortion in Terms of True and False Self” (1960); Green, “The Dead Mother” (1980); Kobrin, The Jihadi Dictionary.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



