Chapter Eleven is called “Venturing Forth into the World,” and that is how a fairy tale begins. In the West the story teaches a child that he will leave home, meet terrifying obstacles, overcome them, and come back safe, more himself, and freer of unhealthy dependency. The extremists tell the same story with a different ending: the child goes out into the world and blows himself up. That is the template of jihad. I think it also helps explain why the Palestinians, and much of the region, stay a regressed tribal herd. House quotes a source close to MBS: “We can’t allow our interests to be forever hostage to Palestinians who can’t get their act together.” That is his view, not mine.
Jews are a tribe too, but our identity does not depend on another religion. In my reading, Islam co-opted the revelation at Sinai and Christianity reopened it and then the PBUH Muhammad claimed Islam to have the last word. That leaves two other identities to negotiate, three Abrahamic faiths instead of a pair, which is far harder psychologically. A pair is the frame for envy, and envy is followed by attacking and splitting the world into black and white thinking.
Behind all of this sits oil. Unconsciously it is the original mother earth’s milk: it gives energy, and it flows from the land. So when Trump tells MBS, “We are defending your oil industry while you’re destroying ours,” and “Drill, baby, drill” is the slogan, the quarrel is really about the breast.
Milk needs a mother, and the PBUH Muhammad remains the maternal figure holding the ummah together. Ummah shares its root with umm, mother. When he died there was no agreed successor, and I read the launch of jihad as the inability to mourn him. Zarqawi did the same in miniature: he mourned his mother for forty days and then began his rampage of beheadings. He was enraged that he had lost his “air supply” and felt he could not live without her.
MBS has not learned this lesson about himself. He wants to “rearrange the living room furniture,” says Norman Roule, “but he can’t do so during a hurricane.” House’s minister says his vision “includes Israel. It’s just going to take longer.” Asked about Palestine, MBS told the Atlantic: “Do I care personally about the Palestinian issue? I don’t but my people do.” He must not fear being honest with his people; only then can they learn from their leader.
Cosmetic change cannot reach the root: how the female is treated in relation to the infant, and the consuming rage of the herd that follows. Asabiyyah, ummah, the ikhwan, mu’akhat, the fantasy of the brother, are defenses against unmet psychological needs. The ideology is a prosthesis, a cane that lets the group “walk” because it cannot recognize the other without hating him. The obsession with the Jew and hence Israel is flypaper, and it does not come off until the population is taught about the problem.
House ends with MBS able to “pull his head in and, like a turtle, close his shell.” In October a report said he was moving between bunkered palaces. On November 10 he greeted the King of Bahrain at Riyadh airport. The turtle comes out for a state visit and goes back in.
Sources:
House, The Man Who Would Be King, Chapter Eleven
Cashdan, S., 2000, The Witch Must Die: The Hidden Meaning of Fairy Tales. New York: Basic Books
Bettelheim, B., 1976, The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales
Mahler, Pine & Bergman, 1975, The Psychological Birth of the Human Infant; see Kobrin 2016, The Jihadi Dictionary, entry “Separation-individuation”
Kobrin 2016, The Jihadi Dictionary, entries “Ummah”, “Brother” and “Activate” (p. 17)
The National, Nov 10 2026: https://www.thenationalnews.com/news/gulf/2026/11/11/king-of-bahrain-meets-saudi-crown-prince-on-visit-to-riyadh/
Daily Pakistan, Oct 12 2026: https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/12-Oct-2026/saudi-crown-prince-mbs-hiding-in-bunkers-amid-houthi-missile-attacks-wsj-report-says
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



