My grandmother had a word for this kind of thinking: narishkeit, foolishness. It fits the statement signed on Sunday by Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Egypt, which declared Israel “the fundamental source of instability in the region and beyond.”
The Jerusalem Post then asked a Gulf analyst, Dr. Ahmed Alkhuzaie, what it meant. His answer: a “broader diplomatic consensus,” Riyadh as “a leading architect of regional stability,” and no reason to rule out the Abraham Accords. Normalization, he said, is now “contingent” on the Palestinian issue.
Look at what is being asked of us. Israel is named as the source of the trouble, and Israel is also expected to remain the door Saudi Arabia may someday walk through, on terms Riyadh sets. We are to be blamed and courted at once. That is the old dhimmi arrangement in modern diplomatic dress: the protected party that must pay, wait, and accept the verdict.
Meanwhile the same statement condemns Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia and on shipping, and the Post’s own related headline reports Houthi strikes paralyzing Riyadh flights. The instability Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is living with did not come from Jerusalem. It comes from Yemen, from the Iran-backed militia next door, which in 2016 fired a missile toward Mecca itself. The pot is calling the kettle black. In classical Arabic they say - Al-jamalu lā yarā ḥadabatahu wa-yarā ḥadabata ghayrih. The camel doesn’t see his own hump but sees the hump in others.
Yet the kingdom that signs a statement calling Israel the source of instability is receiving Israeli help against the Houthis. An Israeli defense official told the Jerusalem Post that IDF intelligence is assisting Saudi Arabia through US mediation. President Trump, asked whether Riyadh should accept Israel’s offer, answered, “Yeah, I do, sure. Israel has been very helpful to Saudi Arabia.” Blame in public, rely in private.
Why would a crown prince who presents himself as a modernizer keep feeding his own people such narishkeit? Because modernizing the cinemas and the roads is easier than modernizing the mind. A ruler who wants obedient children needs a bad object to hold their anger, and the Jew has served that purpose for centuries. If Israel is the villain, the father-ruler stays the good, protecting father, and no one asks why the missiles keep landing on Riyadh. That is splitting, and it keeps a population in a childlike state: dependent, grateful, and unable to ask hard questions about its own leaders. A leader who needs his people infantile is not modernizing them, whatever the new skyline says.
This also makes analysts like Dr. Alkhuzaie superspreaders of antisemitism. They give an ancient accusation the vocabulary of statecraft, and each repetition makes the conflict worse.
What goes around comes around. A kingdom that needs Israel to be the problem will not be able to solve its own.
Sources:
Danielle Greyman-Kennard, “Saudi-signed statement blaming Israel for instability doesn’t rule out Abraham Accords, expert says,” The Jerusalem Post, October 25, 2026.
Trump says Saudi Arabia should accept Israeli help against Houthis, Middle East Eye, October 2026. https://www.middleeasteye.net/live-blog/live-blog-update/trump-says-saudi-arabia-should-accept-israeli-help-against-houthis
Israeli intelligence helps Saudi Arabia target Houthis, The Jerusalem Post, October 22, 2026. https://www.jpost.com/middle-east/article-912598
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv-based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar. https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



