On October 13 in Belfast, Barack Obama said of the Jews who came to the Land of Israel: “They understandably sought a refuge. What is also undeniable is that they took land off people and they were excessive. And those people understandably said, ‘This is injustice and I want my land back.’”
Listen to how that sentence is built. The first half offers the Jews pity as refugees. The second half takes away their history. He grants the Jews millennia of persecution, but not millennia in the land. In Obama’s telling, the Jews arrive from nowhere, as strangers, and help themselves. Three thousand years of Jewish life in the land disappear: Jerusalem, Hebron, Safed, Tiberias, and the communities that never left. What remains is the old figure of the Jew as intruder.
Erasure is a psychic act before it becomes a political one. We make disappear what we cannot bear to hold in mind. When the erasure is spoken to the Jews themselves, it becomes gaslighting: we are asked to doubt our own history and to accept the story of ourselves as intruders.
In my essay on Abdul El-Sayed and Obama, I traced a more intimate version of the same move: two men whose public stories about their own childhoods leave things out. El-Sayed told Meet the Press that his family had no Muslim Brotherhood ties. His half-sister, Eman Abdelhadi, has written otherwise. A man who cannot admit what lies in his own origins finds it easy to deny the origins of others.
On October 24, the first day of early in-person voting in Michigan, Obama will stand beside El-Sayed in Detroit. Sharing a stage does not make one man’s words the other’s. It does give El-Sayed a plain question to answer: Do you agree that the Jews “took land off people” and were “excessive”? He has already given a hint. At last week’s debate, asked whether Israel or Iran is the greater threat to America, he answered: “I think both of them have proven dangerous in their own way.” He should answer it, and he should also tell voters, in his own words, the truth about his family.
We can insist on that much. Quote Obama in full. Put the question to El-Sayed directly, at his events, in letters, and on air. And refuse to let the debate over Israel go forward as if the Jews have no history in their own land.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



