In 1983, when I entered psychoanalytic training as a research candidate who would go on to become a clinician, the term PTSD — coined only three years earlier, in 1980 — was not yet accepted among psychoanalysts, at least not in my own training experience. I found this odd, and frankly exclusionary, since the diagnosis existed precisely to name severe traumatic history. How could a field built on the study of the unconscious turn away from the study of trauma itself? Think—denial. I joined the fledgling Society for Traumatic Stress Studies, founded in 1985, not long after it began. There I became good friends with Harold Kudler, M.D., who worked within the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and later taught as a psychoanalyst and psychiatrist at Duke University. We had interesting years presenting together at international conferences. In 2003, he asked me to help write the chapter on psychoanalytic treatments for Effective Treatments for PTSD, edited by Edna Foa, PhD, who died this year. I did the literature review on psychoanalysis for that chapter. I then went on to become a military contractor earning US security clearance as well as army dog tags. I mention this history because it shapes my perspective on everything that follows. My own path led from there to the mind of the predator in jihad because my doctorate was in 16th c. Islamic literature, to understand the functional and dynamic relationship and traumatic bonding between predator and prey — a question that turns out to bear directly on what happens to the men and women considered here.
The Israeli reader is by now familiar with the vocabulary of a soldier’s return — the intrusive memories, the hypervigilance, the startle response to a slammed door. What gets less attention is why so many suicides cluster not during deployment but afterward, and specifically among the men who served in Yamam, in Border Police, in the units built on the tightest bonds. I want to call this the rupture of the container.
An elite operational unit is not only a fighting force. It is a psychic structure, in the sense the analyst Wilfred Bion gave that word — a concept he did not arrive at from the armchair. Bion had been a tank commander in the First World War, and one of the formative experiences behind his later theory was sitting with a dying young soldier amid heavy shelling, an encounter with unbearable suffering he could not fully let himself absorb in the moment without being destroyed by it himself. Donald Winnicott, working the same territory from a different angle, had his own war: he served as a surgeon on a Royal Navy destroyer in the same conflict and later spoke with sorrow of the friends he lost. Both men spent their subsequent careers theorizing, from opposite sides of the couch, how unbearable experience gets made bearable — Bion described how an infant, flooded with raw and unbearable sensation, cannot process it alone, and that the material has to be received by another mind, held, and returned in a form the infant can actually think rather than simply suffer. He called this container and contained. Winnicott called the reliable presence that makes this possible a holding environment. Both were describing something more elemental than mother-infant psychology; they were describing the basic condition under which any human being processes what would otherwise be unbearable. Bonding, in this sense, is not a comfort added on top of survival. It is close to survival itself — the means by which unthinkable experience gets rendered thinkable at all.
An operational unit reconstitutes this structure among adults. The men and women beside you saw what you saw. They do not need it explained. The unit metabolizes trauma collectively in real time, even when no one names it that way; this is part of why cohesion is prized above almost everything else in selection and training. The container does not eliminate the horror. It renders it survivable — not by softening the content, but by ensuring the content is never held by one mind alone.
Then the operation ends, or the discharge papers come through, or someone moves on to civilian life, and the container disappears. What had been held inside a shared frame is now held by no one. The horror does not diminish; it loses its holding structure. This is a different injury than the trauma itself — it is the trauma arriving late, unaccompanied, into a psychic space with no walls left around it.
Two recent cases illustrate this from opposite directions. An IDF reservist, already diagnosed with PTSD, died by suicide two days before he was due to report following an emergency call-up back to Gaza — the notice reactivated the demand to return to a structure that could no longer actually hold him, and the gap between anticipation and reality proved unsurvivable. A second soldier, who had lost friends in combat and whose mental health deteriorated afterward, took his own life, never having been formally recognized as a trauma casualty at all — an apparatus with no category for a wound that left no shrapnel. His family fought for his right to burial among the war dead, which is almost a literalization of the argument: society could not grant him a place among the wounded because it could not see the wound. It finally did.
A third pattern, drawn more broadly rather than from any single case, shows the container rupturing not around discharge or recall but inside the moment itself. An officer with a documented PTSD diagnosis remains cleared for duty, a clearance that did not fully account for the risks of his condition. Off duty, running an ordinary errand with family, he is confronted without warning by a lethal threat and, acting under a nervous system already primed for danger, kills his attacker. The tragedy is not that a diagnosed man was serving — services need functioning officers — but that the clearance process failed to weigh what an armed, hypervigilant, already-injured mind might do when the worst-case scenario actually arrived. This is a protocol failure, not a personal one, and it recurs.
What this pattern also makes clear is that the container is not a guarantee against the triggering event itself. No amount of holding prevents a hypervigilant nervous system from meeting a genuine lethal threat and reacting to it. What the container appears to determine is what happens after — whether the officer survives. Where a support structure remains actively engaged around him/her afterward, continuing to hold what has occurred rather than withdrawing at the moment s/he most needs it, the worst outcome can be averted even when the triggering tragedy could not have been.
Some will argue from cases like this that a diagnosis of PTSD should categorically disqualify a person from continued service — that an already-primed nervous system carrying a weapon is a risk no institution should accept. The concern is not frivolous. But PTSD is not a fixed state; it fluctuates with treatment, time, and circumstance, closer to a chronic condition that is periodically reviewed than a permanent disqualification. A blanket exclusion would also remove precisely the officers whose experience is most valuable, since the people most likely to carry this diagnosis are often the most operationally seasoned, not the least capable — and it creates a perverse incentive for others to conceal symptoms rather than disclose them, which serves no one. The more precise variable is not the diagnosis but the presence or absence of a functioning container around the person who holds it. An officer with an active, engaged support structure can absorb even the worst outcome and continue. An officer with none is exposed in a way no clearance protocol can fully offset. The question worth asking is not whether a diagnosis should end a career, but whether the institution has verified that a container actually exists around the person it continues to arm.
This breach looks somewhat different for women, and the difference is worth naming rather than absorbing into the general account. More than sixty-five thousand women served in combat and frontline roles during the recent war, and research on Israeli women combat veterans has found that the strongest predictors of their PTSD are not combat exposure alone but exposure compounded by military sexual trauma and by morally injurious events rooted in betrayal — betrayal specifically by the institution and the people within it. Here one thinks of the tatzpitaniyot, the young female lookout soldiers stationed along the Gaza border, killed and the survivors among them, many of whom had raised repeated warnings before October 7th that went unheeded — a betrayal inflicted by being disbelieved and no less institutional for that. For many of the men considered above, the injury is that the container disappears: discharge ends it, a recall notice threatens to reopen a container that can no longer hold, a diagnosis goes unrecognized. For a woman whose trauma includes betrayal from within her own unit, the container itself can be the source of the wound rather than its remedy. That is a different failure mode than breach. It is containment turned toxic from the inside, which may help explain why disclosure is so often delayed by years or decades rather than months — one of the first Israeli women to serve in an undercover Border Police combat unit has spoken publicly about needing more than a decade to understand the psychological toll of her service, and sixteen years before she sought help or spoke of it at all. Any account of container breach that does not distinguish an absent container from a betraying one will miss why women’s paths to help so often look nothing like men’s.
If this reading is right, the clinical and institutional implication is not simply “more PTSD screening.” It is that discharge, recall, and even routine duty clearance need to be treated as points where a psychic structure can silently fail, each requiring a deliberate, engineered accounting for what happens when the mission-shaped hole is not filled. Back2Life’s farm, the peer-support models built by veterans themselves, are intuitively doing exactly this: rebuilding a container by other means. The defense and public-safety establishments’ failure is not primarily a failure of diagnosis. It is a failure to understand that a soldier or officer does not return alone, or serve alone. She and he each carry a mission-shaped hole where a cohort should have remained — a gap no institution has yet learned to fill.
Courts and disciplinary boards asked to weigh these cases would do well to build this principle into their rulings directly: any officer or soldier diagnosed with PTSD who remains armed or on active status should be guaranteed, as a matter of institutional obligation rather than goodwill, a functioning container — a designated peer group, a monitoring clinician, a named point of ongoing contact — whose presence is verified and re-verified for as long as the diagnosis and the weapon coexist. Absence of such a container should itself be treated as a fitness-for-duty failure, not merely an unfortunate gap. Courts cannot restore the bond a shattered unit once provided, but they can require that something answer for it in the meantime.
For those already discharged, the same obligation should not lapse merely because the uniform has been returned. The institution’s duty is to offer a relational contact — a peer liaison, a standing clinical door, a named person who checks in at predictable intervals and at known points of vulnerability such as anniversaries or recall notices — not to monitor, track, or compile a permanent file on someone who has left service. The distinction matters: a container is relational and consented to; surveillance is administrative and imposed without consent. Enrollment can default to automatic at the point of discharge, since PTSD itself suppresses help-seeking, but declining must be honest and free of hidden consequence. Support offered this way should be able to taper and close if the person stabilizes and asks that it end, rather than following someone indefinitely. Handled this way, the obligation answers the moral injury of abandonment without recreating the very loss of autonomy that discharge is supposed to restore.
To the best of my knowledge, no such standing, guaranteed structure yet exists. What Israel currently has is real but partial: a philanthropically funded trauma treatment network, an IDF National Center for Mental Health and Resilience under construction, and a reservist fitness-review policy revised as recently as this year to extend appeal windows and limit how far a diagnosis travels through the chain of command. But the system still runs on disclosure, and disclosure still carries a cost. Reservists have described the review process itself as humiliating and shame is completely underestimated in the PTSD trauma. Some choose to forgo formal recognition altogether rather than risk losing their unit role — which is to say, rather than risk losing the very container this essay has been describing. Until that changes, the container remains something a person must risk everything to keep, rather than something the institution guarantees.
Sources
News coverage
Amid Gaza war, PTSD and suicides spike among Israeli soldiers — The Washington Post
Israel faces rising PTSD and suicide among troops amid ongoing conflicts — Modern Diplomacy
IDF women face PTSD in unique ways and support systems must catch up — Ynet
The trauma no one sees: Israel’s war with PTSD (Inbar Peled) — Ynet
The Trauma No One Sees: Israel’s War With PTSD — The Media Line
‘Like being stripped before my battalion’: Reservists battle new IDF PTSD policy — Ynet
Research using the container concept
Bion’s Trauma and Trauma Theory
Psychoanalysis, Trauma, and Wilfred Bion
Author bio
Dr. Kobrin’s most recent book is A Soldier’s Guide to Hamas’s Genocidal Psychosis: The Unconscious in Psychological Warfare -- Beyond Ideology, Before Words. Atzmaut Press, 2025. Her earlier book, The Banality of Suicide Terrorism, has just been reissued in a new edition. She is currently working on her seventh book Between Empire and Covenant—The Jewish Bond: Lotman, The Refuseniks and The Bukharan Jews, 1977. See her full body of work at her Amazon author page: https://www.amazon.com/stores/author/B002RF9D5Y


