Dara Horn, in her new book The Final Solution to the Jewish Question: A Love Story for the Living, calls antisemitism the Big Lie. In her words, the lie is always the same: Jews are destroying what you value the most. Today the lie wears a new coat. Israel, we are told, is committing genocide.
Horn asks why so many educated people fall for it. History and propaganda explain how the lie spreads. They do not explain why it takes hold. For that we need the earliest of years.
The Unseen Years – Zero to age 3
By the age of three, every child has met the need to hate and the need to have an enemy according to the Turkish Cypriot Muslim psychoanalyst Vamik Volkan. The infant’s world divides into the good mother who feeds and the bad mother who frustrates, and the child cannot yet hold both in one person. The rage that cannot be spoken to the mother needs somewhere to go. It goes to a stranger, a group, a villain.
Maslow built his pyramid of human need on food, safety, belonging and esteem. He left out the foundation beneath the foundation: the maternal matrix, the first relationship, out of which every later need grows. When that matrix fails, the need does not disappear. It goes unmet and turns to rage, and the rage is like a heat seeking missile as it keeps looking for a target.
The Big Lie is the icing on the cake. The cake is the unmet psychological need. The ideology arrives later, in a university seminar or a slogan, and gives the old rage a respectable story. Now it can say: I am not angry at my mother, I am angry at the child-killer i.e. in fantasy the mother who devours her baby. The accusation of genocide, of Jews murdering children, is the oldest charge in the book, the blood libel in modern clothes. It lets the believer hate with a clear conscience, even with a sense of virtue.
The lie also needs a protector. A frightened child does not ask whether the mother is competent. The child needs her to be the protector, because the alternative is unbearable helplessness. Followers of politicians like Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Sayed hear their promise to fight the destroyer with the ears of a child. The leader stands against the enemy, so the leader cannot be given up. When a fact contradicts him, the follower does not revise the image of the protector. The follower turns on whoever points out the contradiction, because that person threatens the only protection on offer. Criticism of the leader is heard as an attack on the self.
That is why facts bounce off. Show a believer the numbers, the context, the legal definition of genocide, and nothing changes. The belief was never built from evidence, so evidence cannot take it apart. It is holding up something else.
There is a hard point here. A protector who cannot be questioned also cannot be corrected, and the people who depend on him cannot demand that he correct himself. The loyalty that comforts them is the same loyalty that leaves them exposed.
Seeing this does not mean mocking the believers. It means understanding what they are afraid of, and recognizing that the need is older than the politics.
What can be done? Not by facts alone, but facts still matter.
First, start where the need starts. The need to hate is met at age three, so the earliest teaching matters most. Kindergarten and early childhood programs can help children learn that one person, a mother or a teacher, can frustrate them and still love them. A child who learns to hold the good and the bad in the same person has less need to split the world into angels and villains later. This is slow work, but it goes to the cause.
Second, offer containment before argument. A believer who feels frightened will hear a list of facts as an attack. Begin by naming the fear, the helplessness and the wish for a protector as a rescue fantasy. Only after the person feels understood can evidence reach them. This is how a good teacher, friend or relative can work.
Third, judge leaders by results, not by the fear they soothe. A protector who cannot be questioned cannot be corrected. Voters, students and followers can learn to ask of any leader, whether Mamdani, El-Sayed or anyone else: what did you actually do, and can you admit a mistake? A leader who cannot answer that question is serving the need, not the people.
Dara Horn’s own remedy points the same way: curiosity about our blind spots. Mine adds that the blind spot has a history, and the history begins in the unseen years zero to age 3.
Sources:
Dara Horn, The Final Solution to the Jewish Question: A Love Story for the Living (Simon & Schuster, 2026): https://www.simonandschuster.ca/books/The-Final-Solution-to-the-Jewish-Question/Dara-Horn/9781668090169
Jewish Insider, “Dara Horn’s shocking new title hides a serious argument about fighting antisemitism” (August 2026): https://jewishinsider.com/2026/08/dara-horn-the-final-solution-antisemitism-bookshelf/
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y




Like Isaiah 5:2 thank you for this Dahlia.
It doesn't help that organizations that were once seen as respectable now issue reports about “genocide” or “genocidal acts” but limit their focus to the State of Israel. People who need an outlet for their latent rage glom on to catchy slogans & ignore true definitions. You know something is twisted when groups like Queers for Palestine” march alongside antisemitic groups