For months, the discourse surrounding the West Bank has been trapped in a toxic loop of action and reaction, provocation and retribution. But following recent violent flare-ups, including attacks on olive harvesters, foreign diplomats, and journalists, we have reached a point where we can no longer look away from what is growing in our own backyard.
Much of what is said abroad about the settlers is unfair. Palestinian provocations are underreported. Foreign activists stage confrontations for the cameras. Diplomats who arrive without coordinating with the IDF should not be surprised by the headlines they get. And the overwhelming majority of the roughly half a million people living in Judea and Samaria are peaceful.
But none of that settles the matter. The violent ones may number only a few hundred, yet they cannot be treated as a footnote. A few hundred people who torch groves and beat farmers in the name of the Jewish people are a problem the State of Israel owns, whether the foreign press reports on it fairly or not.
We know that a story repeated often enough comes to be believed. That holds for the smears against Israel. It also holds for the comforting line that “it’s only a fringe,” which, repeated often enough, lets us avoid looking at ourselves.
The Danger of Becoming What We Fight
I have spent my career studying the minds of perpetrators. One of the oldest observations in my field is what Anna Freud called identification with the aggressor. The frightened person who has been attacked takes on the qualities of the attacker in order to feel less helpless. The victim becomes the one who terrorizes.
That is what I see in the masked young men, the hilltop “boys,” in the hills. They are frightened, enraged, and convinced they are defending their people. In fact they are copying the enemy. The jihadi raids the village at night, and so do they. The jihadi punishes the innocent for the deeds of others, and so do they. Without realizing it, they are handing Hamas a victory it could never win on the battlefield: making us resemble them.
Aggression breeds aggression, and violence breeds violence. We are different. We are עם אחר , a people a part. We do not want to become like them.
Violence knows no boundaries. It erases the line between self and enemy, between law and chaos. That is why we must hold on to our boundaries. A people that keeps its boundaries keeps itself.
A healthy society, like a healthy mind, must be able to contain its own rage rather than act it out. That is the job of the state, and right now it is not doing that job in the hills.
The Strategic Trap of Vigilantism
Every time a masked fringe takes the law into its own hands, it is not defending Israel. It is sabotaging it. Hostile NGOs and governments use these incidents to push for import bans, arms restrictions, and sanctions. Worse, they leave our real allies without ground to stand on when they defend our right to exist.
When the state’s authority reaches from the Lebanese border to Gaza, it cannot fail to police hills half an hour from its own capital. Failing to hold violent extremists accountable is not only a moral failure. It erodes Israeli sovereignty.
The Harder Path
We do not have a partner for peace. That does not lighten our burden. It makes it heavier. Strength is not midnight raids. Strength is discipline, the rule of law, and enforcing it on our own side as firmly as on the other.
If we lose our moral clarity in the hills of Judea and Samaria, we risk losing what we are fighting to protect.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y



