The Jerusalem Post’s revelation this week — that Abdul El-Sayed’s mother, Fatten Fathy Elkomy, spent five years at the Islamic American/African Relief Agency, a Treasury-designated terror-financing operation tied to Hamas, the Taliban, and the precursor network to al-Qaida — reads, on the surface, as an opposition-research find. It is not, or not only. It is a second document, arriving decades late, about a woman whose first and more consequential document was never written at all: the unseen years, the period from birth to about age three when a child’s sense of safety, and of who can be trusted, is laid down before he has words for any of it, and before he will ever be able to consciously recall it.
Vamik Volkan, the Turkish-Cypriot-American psychoanalyst who built a career on the psychology of large groups, dates a related milestone to the same age. By three, Volkan found, a child develops the capacity to locate a hated other outside the self — a capacity that forms alongside the earliest bond with the mother, not after it. A personality that struggles to hold its own demons — envy, shame, a paranoia it cannot examine — may stabilize itself by fixing on an enemy who can carry them instead, the way a heat-seeking missile locks onto whatever target is warmest and nearest, indifferent to whether that target had anything to do with the heat in the first place. Israeli = Jew = Zionist = Genocidaire reads, in this light, less like an argument than a lock-on — a target selected less for what it did than for how well it fits a need already in place.
Dara Horn’s forthcoming The Final Solution to the Jewish Question: A Love Story for the Living is mandatory reading — a documentary record, built from primary sources for a general audience, of the propaganda apparatus that manufactured this equation and exported it. It does necessary work. What it is less positioned to do, as a history rather than a clinical account, is reach the unseen years — the register where a lie like this one is made survivable, and where the work has to continue after Horn’s book closes. Naming the lie matters first: calling a spade a spade, refusing to let it pass as scholarship or as moral courage. Recognizing when a public figure’s rhetoric asks us to carry his own unresolved history matters second. And third, hardest, is not defensive but declarative: to reclaim not only being Jewish but being what we have always been — a people three thousand years old, a nation from the Middle East, the ground I walk on every day I wake up here.
Cognitive science puts a number on what “unseen” means. Lakoff and Johnson’s rule of thumb, converged on independently by Bargh and Chartrand’s work on automaticity and by Kahneman’s two-system model, holds that roughly ninety-five percent of thought never reaches consciousness. Whatever bond formed between Elkomy and her son in those years would, on ordinary developmental grounds, have been real — that is what those years are generally for. She is not merely a birth mother, as though he had been given up for adoption at hour one and raised without her from the start. She is his mother; the record does not support treating that as incidental. Court records show he and his father, Mohamed El-Sayed, and his mother divorced in Missouri in 1988, when Abdul was roughly three — the precise edge of that window. She remarried outside the bloodline; under the custom she and her family answered to, custody passed to his father’s side before he was out of preschool.
A rupture at that age is not, developmentally, an event a child can describe or fully process. It tends to register as an absence with no name attached to it — which may be why El-Sayed’s memoir gives his mother one paragraph and his father, stepmother, and wife pages of feeling.
That is where the IARA years become relevant, and for a different reason than the Post’s framing suggests. By 1999 El-Sayed was fifteen; by 2004, when Treasury designated IARA and named a former bin Laden lieutenant as director of its Afghanistan operations, he was twenty — Michigan, then Michigan again, then a Rhodes scholarship ahead of him. These are not the unseen years. They are, on a psychoanalytic reading, a second vulnerability window — adolescence and early adulthood, when identity is actively being pledged — arriving just as a mother largely absent since early childhood would, for the first time, have been reachable as an adult with a documented record of her own. Whether or how that registered for him is not something the public record can answer. What the record can note is the coincidence of timing, and a pattern common to unprocessed early loss: keeping the lost parent as an absence rather than a person makes it easier to leave both her departure and her associations unexamined.
He has said, of the attack on a Michigan synagogue preschool, “hurt people hurt people” — a line that, whatever else it intends, relocates the discomfort of that moment onto a general mechanism rather than a person who made a choice. A memoir called Healing Politics that gives so little space to what, in his own account, there was to heal from invites the question of what the silence is doing.
None of this proves El-Sayed shares his mother’s associations. It raises a more crucial and more lasting question: whether the boy who lost her at three and the man who will not discuss her at forty-two are running the same defense — keep the loss unlocated, keep it wordless, keep it someone else’s fault. Horn’s forthcoming history will document what IARA did and whom it funded. Rabbi Tarfon taught that it is not your responsibility to finish the work, but neither are you free to desist from it. We would do well to look closely now at why Abdul El-Sayed has spent four decades looking away from his own past.
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar specializing in the psychology of terrorism and jihadi violence. Her most recent book is A Soldier’s Guide to Hamas’s Genocidal Psychosis—The Unconscious in Psychological Warfare: Beyond Ideology, Before Words. Atzmaut Press, 2025.
https://www.amazon.com/stores/Nancy-Kobrin/author/B002RF9D5Y


