On October 29, the New York Times reported that in the summer of 2016 the FBI and the Department of Homeland Security investigated Ilhan Omar’s 2009 marriage to Ahmed Nur Said Elmi and “found some evidence suggesting it was fraudulent.” Six current and former officials told the paper that agents found evidence suggesting the two were siblings. When immigration officials asked Elmi for more proof that the marriage was real, he left the country and abandoned his green-card petition rather than answer. The case stalled not because anyone cleared her but because prosecutors concluded it fell outside the five-year statute of limitations. As the conservative commentator Erick Erickson put it, the statute of limitations is not an exoneration. Officials did not say what the evidence was, and it remains unproven that Elmi is her brother. Omar has not been charged, and she denies the allegation. But note the year. In 2016, the same summer federal agents were finding evidence, Omar told Minnesota Public Radio that the insinuations were “absurd and offensive.”
I write from long acquaintance. I lived for thirty years in St. Paul, home to one of the largest Somali communities outside Africa, and my doctorate is in Islamic literature. In 2005 I trained Hennepin County sheriff’s deputies on jihad and conducted interviews in the county jail. In 2023 I was a guest of the Somaliland government at the Hargeisa International Book Fair on account of my fifth book The Last Two Jews of Mogadishu Living Under Al Shabaab’s Fire in which I tried to do pidyon shvuim, redemption of the captives for a Somali born Jewish mother and son cf. below. I have kept close ties with Somalilanders, who built a stable democracy in the north while Mogadishu, where Omar was born, fell to clan war.
The reporter Catherine Herridge put it simply: “There are certain facts in life that one should know without reservation: date of birth, given name at birth, and whether you married your brother.” Omar’s answers on all three have the same shape. Asked by Chris Hayes whether she is related to her former husband, she said, “Not to my knowledge.” When federal prosecutors named her in a court filing as “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a/k/a Ilhan Abdullahi Omar,” she wrote, “My name has always been Ilhan Omar,” and turned the question to the vice president’s name. In May 2019, four months after she took her seat, her staff had her listed birth year changed from 1981 to 1982, according to emails reviewed by the New York Post. And in the same interview with Hayes she described a “basic,” working-class life, renting her homes and driving a 2016 Camry, although her 2024 disclosure listed up to $30 million before she amended it to no more than $65,000, and her campaign paid her husband’s firm about $3 million.
The British psychoanalyst John Steiner wrote a famous paper about this state of mind, called “Turning a Blind Eye.” He took it from Sophocles. Oedipus marries his mother, and the play is usually read as the story of a man who did not know. Steiner noticed that almost everyone around Oedipus half-knew: Jocasta, the shepherd who saved the infant, the prophet Tiresias. The truth was available, but it was kept at a distance, not denied and not admitted. Steiner called this a retreat from reality, a way of knowing and not knowing at the same time so that no one has to act on what is known. Freud called this disavowal. A statute of limitations is the institutional version: the truth is held at a distance until the clock runs out.
“Not to my knowledge” is that retreat in four words. It does not say no. It places the knowledge somewhere else, outside the self, where it cannot be questioned. Psychoanalytically, this is not the same as lying. It is a mind that has arranged not to look. In a shame-honor culture, this arrangement is shared. Some facts are known by everyone in the family and spoken by no one, because to speak them would shame the whole line. Somalis have a proverb for it: “Nin reer u weyn iyo naag naago ka ummulisay waxay og yihiin ma sheegaan.” The eldest man of the family and the midwife do not tell everything they know. The midwife knows the birth; the elder knows the lineage. Between them they hold two of Herridge’s three facts, and the proverb says they keep them. I saw the same silence in the Hennepin County jail, where not one young man would say he belonged to a gang. Everyone knew. No one knew.
But the blind eye in this story was not only hers. In 2018 the Times profiled Omar as a refugee with a “soft voice” and “delicate features” whose private life had become “fodder for conservative bloggers.” A year later its fact check of the brother allegation relied largely on her own denials and concluded that “no proof has emerged.” People who asked the question were treated as bigots. A great newspaper, wanting a story about a brave Muslim refugee, did what the clan does. It decided what it would not see. That is how a Western institution comes to protect someone as if she were family.
The Somalilanders I know understand this better than most Americans. They broke away from Mogadishu’s clan politics, held elections, and transferred power peacefully. Their democracy rests on a simple idea that the clan resists: a person answers for herself, and the facts of her life belong to her, not to the family or to the people protecting her.
Oedipus’s story ends when he stops not knowing. Once he sees the truth, he puts out his own eyes, but he also says it aloud and takes it as his own. He does not answer “not to my knowledge.” The Times has now begun to look. Somalis say, “Fari qorrax ma qariso.” A finger cannot hide the sun. The question is whether Omar can look too, and answer, in her own name, the three questions everyone should be able to answer without reservation.
Sources
New York Times, report on the 2016 FBI and DHS inquiry into Omar’s marriage, October 29, 2026. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/29/us/immigration-fraud-claims-ilhan-omar.html
Erick Erickson, “The Statute of Limitations Is Not an Exoneration,” October 30, 2026. https://erickerickson.substack.com
Washington Free Beacon, “After Shaming Conservatives for ‘Seizing’ on ‘Rumors,’ NYT Finally Concedes Ilhan Omar (Probably) Married Her Brother,” October 29, 2026. https://freebeacon.com/media/after-shaming-conservatives-for-seizing-on-rumors-nyt-finally-concedes-ilhan-omar-probably-married-her-brother/
Washington Free Beacon, “Ilhan Omar Claims She’s Struggling Financially…,” October 26, 2026. https://freebeacon.com/democrats/ilhan-omar-claims-shes-struggling-financially-taxpayers-paid-her-rent-while-her-husbands-company-raked-in-millions-from-indian-billionaire/
Catherine Herridge, as quoted in the Huckabee Post, October 26, 2026. https://huckabeepost.substack.com
New York Post, reporting on the U.S. Attorney’s motion and the change to Omar’s listed birth year, October 2026. https://nypost.com
VINnews, “Ilhan Omar Hits Back At Trump, Challenges Vance Over His Name,” October 23, 2026. https://vinnews.com/2026/10/23/ilhan-omar-hits-back-at-trump-challenges-vance-over-his-name/
Sophocles, Oedipus the King; Sigmund Freud, “Fetishism” (1927); John Steiner, “Turning a Blind Eye: The Cover Up for Oedipus,” International Review of Psycho-Analysis 12 (1985): 161–172.
Somali proverbs, from collected maahmaah. https://africanmanners.wordpress.com/2012/07/07/somali-proverbs-100-in-total/
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, is a Tel Aviv–based psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar.
https://www.amazon.com/Nancy-Kobrin/e/B002RF9D5Y




Thank you for reading closely and for the care you’ve taken. I agree with your last point, which is why my piece does not accuse her of lying. I wrote that “not to my knowledge” is “not the same as lying.” My subject was disavowal, the state of knowing and not knowing at the same time. But several of your points don’t hold up against the record.
On the brother: she has denied it, and I said so. But “not to my knowledge” is exactly the problem. Whether you are related to the man you married is something a person knows. And the suspicion was never only about a green card. According to the New York Times on October 29, six current and former officials said the 2016 FBI and DHS inquiry found evidence suggesting that she and Elmi were siblings. The case stalled because the statute of limitations had run, not because anyone cleared her.
On the name: I did not claim she signed official documents under another name. I reported that federal prosecutors themselves, in a court filing, call her “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a/k/a Ilhan Abdullahi Omar,” and that her answer was to point to the vice president’s name.
On the birth year: according to emails reviewed by the New York Post, in May 2019 her staff had her listed birth year changed from 1981 to 1982. If 1981 appeared somewhere, someone put it there, and the question of her age is now the center of a federal investigation.
On the money: I did not say she had $30 million. I wrote that her 2024 disclosure listed up to $30 million before she amended it to no more than $65,000. An error of that size, on a document signed under penalty of law, is itself what the U.S. Attorney in Washington says she is now examining.
None of this proves a crime, and I said that as well. My argument is narrower: a person should be able to answer three questions about herself without reservation. So far she has not.
Haven’t read it yet - not knowing her own name is … interesting.