Thank you for reading closely and for the care you’ve taken. I agree with your last point, which is why my piece does not accuse her of lying. I wrote that “not to my knowledge” is “not the same as lying.” My subject was disavowal, the state of knowing and not knowing at the same time. But several of your points don’t hold up against the record.
On the brother: she has denied it, and I said so. But “not to my knowledge” is exactly the problem. Whether you are related to the man you married is something a person knows. And the suspicion was never only about a green card. According to the New York Times on October 29, six current and former officials said the 2016 FBI and DHS inquiry found evidence suggesting that she and Elmi were siblings. The case stalled because the statute of limitations had run, not because anyone cleared her.
On the name: I did not claim she signed official documents under another name. I reported that federal prosecutors themselves, in a court filing, call her “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a/k/a Ilhan Abdullahi Omar,” and that her answer was to point to the vice president’s name.
On the birth year: according to emails reviewed by the New York Post, in May 2019 her staff had her listed birth year changed from 1981 to 1982. If 1981 appeared somewhere, someone put it there, and the question of her age is now the center of a federal investigation.
On the money: I did not say she had $30 million. I wrote that her 2024 disclosure listed up to $30 million before she amended it to no more than $65,000. An error of that size, on a document signed under penalty of law, is itself what the U.S. Attorney in Washington says she is now examining.
None of this proves a crime, and I said that as well. My argument is narrower: a person should be able to answer three questions about herself without reservation. So far she has not.
Abdiqani Muse thank you for this important criticism. You are absolutely right and I only know a little af-Somali and I know that there are many significant differences. Actually as I type when I tried to learn a little af-Somali in 2005 I was corresponding with Rami Mordechai, a Somali born Jewish young man in Mogadishu and he laughed at me in an email because he said my dictionary must be from the north. It was very hard back then to find a dictionary of the language. Mahadsanid.
I'm not a fan of Ilhan Omar, but I think some of the facts speak in her favor rather than against her. For instance, she did deny strenuously that her former husband was her brother. She said "not to my knowledge" only about whether she was related. And the suspicion that she had committed marriage fraud appears to be that the marriage was a sham to get him a green card, not that he was her brother.
Also, she has never gone by any name on official records other that Ilhan Abdullahi Omar, and on official records has always given her birth year as 1982. Finally, the report that her net worth was $30 million was an accounting error -- she never had anything close to that amount.
That's not to say she always tells the truth. But it is important not to accuse her of lying on these points when the evidence we have doesn't support the accusation.
Thank you for reading closely and for the care you've taken. I agree with your last point, which is why my piece does not accuse her of lying. I wrote that "not to my knowledge" is "not the same as lying." My subject was disavowal, the state of knowing and not knowing at the same time. But several of your points don't hold up against the record.
On the brother: she has denied it, and I said so. But "not to my knowledge" is exactly the problem. Whether you are related to the man you married is something a person knows. And the suspicion was never only about a green card. According to the New York Times on October 29, six current and former officials said the 2016 FBI and DHS inquiry found evidence suggesting that she and Elmi were siblings. The case stalled because the statute of limitations had run, not because anyone cleared her.
On the name: I did not claim she signed official documents under another name. I reported that federal prosecutors themselves, in a court filing, call her "Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a/k/a Ilhan Abdullahi Omar," and that her answer was to point to the vice president's name.
On the birth year: according to emails reviewed by the New York Post, in May 2019 her staff had her listed birth year changed from 1981 to 1982. If 1981 appeared somewhere, someone put it there, and the question of her age is now the center of a federal investigation.
On the money: I did not say she had $30 million. I wrote that her 2024 disclosure listed up to $30 million before she amended it to no more than $65,000. An error of that size, on a document signed under penalty of law, is itself what the U.S. Attorney in Washington says she is now examining.
None of this proves a crime, and I said that as well. My argument is narrower: a person should be able to answer three questions about herself without reservation. So far she has not.
What a great piece! I genuinely enjoyed reading it.
One important cultural point, though: the proverb you quoted belongs to Somaliland’s cultural heritage. It should not automatically be attributed to all Somali-speaking communities in Somalia, Ethiopia or Kenya.
We may share a language, but that doesn’t mean we share the same culture, history, traditions or identity. Somalilanders have their own distinct cultural and historical identity. This distinction is often overlooked and is one of the reasons why Somaliland’s identity and voice are so frequently misunderstood internationally.
One of the biggest problems is that all Somali-speaking communities across the Horn of Africa are often treated as one homogeneous group, when in reality, our histories, cultures and political aspirations are different.
Nevertheless, I thoroughly enjoyed reading your article. Thank you for sharing such an interesting perspective!
Thank you for reading closely and for the care you’ve taken. I agree with your last point, which is why my piece does not accuse her of lying. I wrote that “not to my knowledge” is “not the same as lying.” My subject was disavowal, the state of knowing and not knowing at the same time. But several of your points don’t hold up against the record.
On the brother: she has denied it, and I said so. But “not to my knowledge” is exactly the problem. Whether you are related to the man you married is something a person knows. And the suspicion was never only about a green card. According to the New York Times on October 29, six current and former officials said the 2016 FBI and DHS inquiry found evidence suggesting that she and Elmi were siblings. The case stalled because the statute of limitations had run, not because anyone cleared her.
On the name: I did not claim she signed official documents under another name. I reported that federal prosecutors themselves, in a court filing, call her “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a/k/a Ilhan Abdullahi Omar,” and that her answer was to point to the vice president’s name.
On the birth year: according to emails reviewed by the New York Post, in May 2019 her staff had her listed birth year changed from 1981 to 1982. If 1981 appeared somewhere, someone put it there, and the question of her age is now the center of a federal investigation.
On the money: I did not say she had $30 million. I wrote that her 2024 disclosure listed up to $30 million before she amended it to no more than $65,000. An error of that size, on a document signed under penalty of law, is itself what the U.S. Attorney in Washington says she is now examining.
None of this proves a crime, and I said that as well. My argument is narrower: a person should be able to answer three questions about herself without reservation. So far she has not.
Haven’t read it yet - not knowing her own name is … interesting.
Abdiqani Muse thank you for this important criticism. You are absolutely right and I only know a little af-Somali and I know that there are many significant differences. Actually as I type when I tried to learn a little af-Somali in 2005 I was corresponding with Rami Mordechai, a Somali born Jewish young man in Mogadishu and he laughed at me in an email because he said my dictionary must be from the north. It was very hard back then to find a dictionary of the language. Mahadsanid.
I'm not a fan of Ilhan Omar, but I think some of the facts speak in her favor rather than against her. For instance, she did deny strenuously that her former husband was her brother. She said "not to my knowledge" only about whether she was related. And the suspicion that she had committed marriage fraud appears to be that the marriage was a sham to get him a green card, not that he was her brother.
Also, she has never gone by any name on official records other that Ilhan Abdullahi Omar, and on official records has always given her birth year as 1982. Finally, the report that her net worth was $30 million was an accounting error -- she never had anything close to that amount.
That's not to say she always tells the truth. But it is important not to accuse her of lying on these points when the evidence we have doesn't support the accusation.
Thank you for reading closely and for the care you've taken. I agree with your last point, which is why my piece does not accuse her of lying. I wrote that "not to my knowledge" is "not the same as lying." My subject was disavowal, the state of knowing and not knowing at the same time. But several of your points don't hold up against the record.
On the brother: she has denied it, and I said so. But "not to my knowledge" is exactly the problem. Whether you are related to the man you married is something a person knows. And the suspicion was never only about a green card. According to the New York Times on October 29, six current and former officials said the 2016 FBI and DHS inquiry found evidence suggesting that she and Elmi were siblings. The case stalled because the statute of limitations had run, not because anyone cleared her.
On the name: I did not claim she signed official documents under another name. I reported that federal prosecutors themselves, in a court filing, call her "Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a/k/a Ilhan Abdullahi Omar," and that her answer was to point to the vice president's name.
On the birth year: according to emails reviewed by the New York Post, in May 2019 her staff had her listed birth year changed from 1981 to 1982. If 1981 appeared somewhere, someone put it there, and the question of her age is now the center of a federal investigation.
On the money: I did not say she had $30 million. I wrote that her 2024 disclosure listed up to $30 million before she amended it to no more than $65,000. An error of that size, on a document signed under penalty of law, is itself what the U.S. Attorney in Washington says she is now examining.
None of this proves a crime, and I said that as well. My argument is narrower: a person should be able to answer three questions about herself without reservation. So far she has not.
What a great piece! I genuinely enjoyed reading it.
One important cultural point, though: the proverb you quoted belongs to Somaliland’s cultural heritage. It should not automatically be attributed to all Somali-speaking communities in Somalia, Ethiopia or Kenya.
We may share a language, but that doesn’t mean we share the same culture, history, traditions or identity. Somalilanders have their own distinct cultural and historical identity. This distinction is often overlooked and is one of the reasons why Somaliland’s identity and voice are so frequently misunderstood internationally.
One of the biggest problems is that all Somali-speaking communities across the Horn of Africa are often treated as one homogeneous group, when in reality, our histories, cultures and political aspirations are different.
Nevertheless, I thoroughly enjoyed reading your article. Thank you for sharing such an interesting perspective!