Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin's avatar

Thank you, Peter. The theology is real and it matters. Jeffrey Herf documented the Nazi propaganda piece in Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World. But scripture does not explain why so many take it up with such passion, while others read the same texts and do not kill. Theology gives permission and a vocabulary. The hatred itself is rooted much earlier, in the first years of life, when the child is not allowed to separate from the mother and cannot tolerate difference. The Jew becomes the one onto whom all that unbearable rage and shame is projected. That is why I look at the psychology underneath the texts and not only at the texts. Both are needed to see the whole picture.

Mr. Ala's avatar

I have no reason to doubt you at all, except: Freudianism? Really? You do not regard (I almost typed “know”) that theory as exploded?

3 more comments...

Ready for more?