Thank you, Peter. The theology is real and it matters. Jeffrey Herf documented the Nazi propaganda piece in Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World. But scripture does not explain why so many take it up with such passion, while others read the same texts and do not kill. Theology gives permission and a vocabulary. The hatred itself is rooted much earlier, in the first years of life, when the child is not allowed to separate from the mother and cannot tolerate difference. The Jew becomes the one onto whom all that unbearable rage and shame is projected. That is why I look at the psychology underneath the texts and not only at the texts. Both are needed to see the whole picture.
Then, for you as a Jew, there is s further theological explanation.
Muslim Antisemitism
Allah and Muhammad planned the genocide of the Jews more than 1400 years ago:
Muslim anti-Semitism originated in the 7th century, with Muhammad (d. 632 AD).
Islamic scripture, including the Koran and Hadith, describes the Jewish community of Yathrib (now Medina) repeatedly refusing to convert to Islam when asked to, and mocking Muhammad’s claim to be God’s final prophet in the Jewish and Christian tradition.
Muhammad then cursed the Jews, calling them “the offspring of apes and pigs” and condemning them in this world and the next.
Islamic teaching instructs Muslims to love what Allah loves and hate what Allah hates. Allah loves Muslims and hates disbelievers.
The Koran calls on Muslims to hate all non-Muslims, based on the example of the “prophet Ibrahim” (Genesis’s Abraham), who broke away from his fellow tribesmen with the following words and rationale:
“We renounce you. Enmity and hate shall forever reign between us — until you believe in Allah alone” (Koran 60:4)
The Jews—who rejected Islam and mocked Muhammad—are Islam’s most hated and persistent enemy. This is underscored by Koran 5:82:
“You will find the most vehement of the people in hostility to the believers to be the Jews.”
Muslim Jew-hatred is reflected in various Hadith, such as the one that is part of the Hamas Charter:
“The Day of Judgement will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jews will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say ‘O Muslim, there is a Jew behind me, come and slaughter him.’”
Islamic anti-Semitism has intensified in modern times. During the 1930s and 40s, Nazi propaganda exacerbated Muslim Arab eliminationism..
Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, collaborated closely with the Nazis during World War II. Al-Husseini met with Hitler and other Nazi leaders, endorsed their anti-Semitic views, promoted Nazi propaganda claims, and encouraged Arab Islamists to back the Nazi war effort.
Through this connection, Adolf Hitler’s book, Mein Kampf, was translated into Arabic, and is to this day widely read and revered in the Islamic world for its anti-Jewish content.
Pakistan’s famed Ulema scholar, Sheikh Maulana Mawdudi has expressed admiration for “the ingenious and mighty leadership of Adolf Hitler and his comrades.”
Hezbollah leader Hasan Nasrullah has echoed Nazi racial sentiments, stating:
“If we searched the entire world for a person more cowardly, despicable, weak and feeble in psyche, mind, ideology and religion, we would not find anyone like the Jew.”
Sermonising against Israel on Egypt's Al-Rahma TV in October 2009, Egyptian cleric Hazem Shuman stated:
“It has been proven that the Jews are like a cancer – if they are not removed from the body of the [Islamic] nation, they will kill the entire nation.”
Another key factor is the belief that once a place has been ruled by Islam, it remains the rightful property of Muslims forever.
Koran 2:191:
“Kill them wherever you come upon them and drive them out of the places from which they have driven you out.”
Israel, part of the Middle East under Muslim control from 636 AD—with a brief interlude of Crusader occupation—until the fall of the Ottoman Empire in 1917 is thus viewed by Muslim Arabs (and indeed the entire Islamic Ummah) as Islamic land that must be reclaimed.
Ahmad Bahr, Deputy Speaker of the Hamas Parliament, stated on Al-Aqsa TV in 2012:
“If the enemy sets foot on a single square inch of Islamic land, Jihad becomes an individual duty, incumbent on every Muslim, male or female.”
Speaking at a Gaza public rally in 2012, Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal proclaimed:
“Since Palestine is ours, and it is the land of the Arabs and Islam, it is unthinkable that we would recognise the legitimacy of the Israeli occupation of it ... Let me emphasise that we adhere to this fundameintal principle: We do not recognize Israel … The Palestinian resistance will crush it and sweep it away, be it Allah’s will.”
Such statements convey a brief sample of Islamic anti-Semitism and eliminationism. An absolute denial of the right of the Jews to a homeland of their own, on lands that traditionally belonged to the Jewish people for over two millennia before the advent of Muhammad.
Then there is also the straight, conscious theological motivation.
Whenever a terrorist outrage occurs in the West, apologists for Islam blow their usual smoke about “lone wolf attack” and mental health issues.”
But what if the attacker’s actions make perfect sense according to mainstream Islamic theology?
None of the analysis below is an outlier interpretation of Islamic scripture.
Any Muslim with only a nominal commitment to Islam is just one imam and a desire for a closer religious commitment away from becoming a terrorist seeking martyrdom for the sake of Allah.
This forces us into a game of Muslim Roulette with every Muslim, since we have no way of knowing what is in his heart until he decides to act out on it.
A Muslim In Name Only [MINO] who decides to get serious about his Islamic religion soon finds out that jihad is an essential element of Islam. A core tenet.
This isn't some fringe teaching that nobody cares about. It is a central purpose of Islam. Jihad is obligatory for all Muslims until all non-Muslims have been subjugated to Islamic law.
After one’s Islamic belief, jihad to advance Islamic dominance is a Muslim’s crowning achievement.
Sahih Bukhari: V1B2N25:
“Allah’s Apostle was asked, ‘What is the best deed?’ He replied, ‘To believe in Allah and His Apostle Muhammad.’ The questioner then asked, ‘What is the next best in goodness? He replied, To participate in Jihad, religious fighting in Allah's Cause.’”
This political goal is a Muslim's religious duty. Muhammad didn't approve of sitting around knobbing your palm. He said the way to prove your devotion to Allah is by action.
Koran 4: 95:
“Allah prefers Jihadists who strive hard and fight above those who sit home. He has distinguished his fighters with a huge reward.”
And what is this “huge reward”?
Islam teaches that one can never be certain of his or her ultimate salvation. The only sure way to enter paradise is to die in an act of martyrdom for Allah. That's how you get a Muslim terrorist.
And that’s what makes Islam so dangerous Any Westernised Muslim who may have gone off the rails a bit is easy meat for a jihadi recruiter.
A Westernised Muslim is often caught between living as a Muslim, and living in a more secular, Western manner.
His alienation, both from his cultural roots and the wider Westernised milieu in which he moves, can be readily exploited by someone offering a sense of identity, purpose, and belonging.
The new recruit learns that by recommitting to Islam and becoming shahid, once the first drop of his blood is shed for Allah, all his sins are forgiven and he is guaranteed paradise.
This explains why in advance of carrying out their pre-planned attack, many of the 9/11 terrorists reportedly drank alcohol, ate pork, and visited nudie bars, things normally haram [forbidden] in Islam.
Not only are his own sins forgiven, but the shahid gets to intercede on Judgement Day for seventy family members, who will be spared from the hellfire and enter paradise in honor of the martyr.
Sunan Abi Dawud 2522: Book 15, Hadith 46:
“The Prophet said: The intercession of a martyr will be accepted for seventy members of his family.”
Highly attractive to someone who fell into secular, un-Islamic ways and returns to Islam wanting to make it up to his family and to Allah.
This, I think, explains why the second- and third-generations of immigrant stock are disproportionately involved in terrorist activity.
I’d be interested to read your thesis as referred to above, since it’s not something I’d been previously exposed to or considered.
My essay below suggests another psycho-sexual stand to the development of the jihadi impulse.
Something not usually reported is that unmarried Muslim men denied access to women typically experience sex first with other males.
While Islam prohibits adult homosexuality, man-boy sex is tacitly condoned because the boy is not considered a man yet.
Muslim men acting out sexually with boys argue that falling in love with or identifying as a homosexual man is the ultimate sin. Consequently, they reframe the exploitation of a young boy as a transactional act of physical gratification or dominance rather than an emotional relationship.
Because the boy is prepubescent or adolescent and lacks a beard, he is treated structurally as a possession rather than a "man," allowing the abuser to maintain his public standing as a straight, masculine figure within a deeply homophobic society.
This rationalisation is particularly prevalent in countries like Pakistan and Afghanistan, where they even have a saying: “Women are for babies, boys are for pleasure.”
Female doctors working with Afghan women in Northern Pakistan refugee camps reported a startling phenomenon: an epidemic of married women experiencing difficulty in falling pregnant and seeking medical advice for this problem.
Examination overwhelmingly disclosed no medical reasons for this. Follow-up questioning disclosed the women’s husbands were copulating with their wives solely in the manner they’d learned through their early sexual experiences with other males.
In a culture in which sex is never publicly discussed, neither husbands nor wives knew any better.
In Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Gaza, Egypt, and other Middle Eastern countries, the phrase “breaking his eye” is used to describe male-on-male anal rape. It is typically deployed by an older aggressor to boast about his dominance over a younger, weaker boy.
A troubling example of this mindset occurred in Germany, where a ten-year-old native German boy was rapied in a playground toilet by a married Muslim asylum seeker, whose wife had remained behind in his country of origin.
The attacker told the judge “it was a sexual emergency,” further underscoring the dangerous sexual attitudes that Muslim migrants may bring with them.
It is clear that for many Muslim men, sex is not about mutuality, but about the achievement of pleasure through the violent domination of others, often making sense of one’s own pederastic abuse by visiting it upon others.
Part of the jihad impulse may be explained as the terrorist violating the masculinity of the Kuffaar, just his masculinity was once violated.
Thank you, Peter. The theology is real and it matters. Jeffrey Herf documented the Nazi propaganda piece in Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World. But scripture does not explain why so many take it up with such passion, while others read the same texts and do not kill. Theology gives permission and a vocabulary. The hatred itself is rooted much earlier, in the first years of life, when the child is not allowed to separate from the mother and cannot tolerate difference. The Jew becomes the one onto whom all that unbearable rage and shame is projected. That is why I look at the psychology underneath the texts and not only at the texts. Both are needed to see the whole picture.
I have no reason to doubt you at all, except: Freudianism? Really? You do not regard (I almost typed “know”) that theory as exploded?
Then, for you as a Jew, there is s further theological explanation.
Muslim Antisemitism
Allah and Muhammad planned the genocide of the Jews more than 1400 years ago:
Muslim anti-Semitism originated in the 7th century, with Muhammad (d. 632 AD).
Islamic scripture, including the Koran and Hadith, describes the Jewish community of Yathrib (now Medina) repeatedly refusing to convert to Islam when asked to, and mocking Muhammad’s claim to be God’s final prophet in the Jewish and Christian tradition.
Muhammad then cursed the Jews, calling them “the offspring of apes and pigs” and condemning them in this world and the next.
Islamic teaching instructs Muslims to love what Allah loves and hate what Allah hates. Allah loves Muslims and hates disbelievers.
The Koran calls on Muslims to hate all non-Muslims, based on the example of the “prophet Ibrahim” (Genesis’s Abraham), who broke away from his fellow tribesmen with the following words and rationale:
“We renounce you. Enmity and hate shall forever reign between us — until you believe in Allah alone” (Koran 60:4)
The Jews—who rejected Islam and mocked Muhammad—are Islam’s most hated and persistent enemy. This is underscored by Koran 5:82:
“You will find the most vehement of the people in hostility to the believers to be the Jews.”
Muslim Jew-hatred is reflected in various Hadith, such as the one that is part of the Hamas Charter:
“The Day of Judgement will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jews will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say ‘O Muslim, there is a Jew behind me, come and slaughter him.’”
Islamic anti-Semitism has intensified in modern times. During the 1930s and 40s, Nazi propaganda exacerbated Muslim Arab eliminationism..
Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, collaborated closely with the Nazis during World War II. Al-Husseini met with Hitler and other Nazi leaders, endorsed their anti-Semitic views, promoted Nazi propaganda claims, and encouraged Arab Islamists to back the Nazi war effort.
Through this connection, Adolf Hitler’s book, Mein Kampf, was translated into Arabic, and is to this day widely read and revered in the Islamic world for its anti-Jewish content.
Pakistan’s famed Ulema scholar, Sheikh Maulana Mawdudi has expressed admiration for “the ingenious and mighty leadership of Adolf Hitler and his comrades.”
Hezbollah leader Hasan Nasrullah has echoed Nazi racial sentiments, stating:
“If we searched the entire world for a person more cowardly, despicable, weak and feeble in psyche, mind, ideology and religion, we would not find anyone like the Jew.”
Sermonising against Israel on Egypt's Al-Rahma TV in October 2009, Egyptian cleric Hazem Shuman stated:
“It has been proven that the Jews are like a cancer – if they are not removed from the body of the [Islamic] nation, they will kill the entire nation.”
Another key factor is the belief that once a place has been ruled by Islam, it remains the rightful property of Muslims forever.
Koran 2:191:
“Kill them wherever you come upon them and drive them out of the places from which they have driven you out.”
Israel, part of the Middle East under Muslim control from 636 AD—with a brief interlude of Crusader occupation—until the fall of the Ottoman Empire in 1917 is thus viewed by Muslim Arabs (and indeed the entire Islamic Ummah) as Islamic land that must be reclaimed.
Ahmad Bahr, Deputy Speaker of the Hamas Parliament, stated on Al-Aqsa TV in 2012:
“If the enemy sets foot on a single square inch of Islamic land, Jihad becomes an individual duty, incumbent on every Muslim, male or female.”
Speaking at a Gaza public rally in 2012, Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal proclaimed:
“Since Palestine is ours, and it is the land of the Arabs and Islam, it is unthinkable that we would recognise the legitimacy of the Israeli occupation of it ... Let me emphasise that we adhere to this fundameintal principle: We do not recognize Israel … The Palestinian resistance will crush it and sweep it away, be it Allah’s will.”
Such statements convey a brief sample of Islamic anti-Semitism and eliminationism. An absolute denial of the right of the Jews to a homeland of their own, on lands that traditionally belonged to the Jewish people for over two millennia before the advent of Muhammad.
ENDS
Then there is also the straight, conscious theological motivation.
Whenever a terrorist outrage occurs in the West, apologists for Islam blow their usual smoke about “lone wolf attack” and mental health issues.”
But what if the attacker’s actions make perfect sense according to mainstream Islamic theology?
None of the analysis below is an outlier interpretation of Islamic scripture.
Any Muslim with only a nominal commitment to Islam is just one imam and a desire for a closer religious commitment away from becoming a terrorist seeking martyrdom for the sake of Allah.
This forces us into a game of Muslim Roulette with every Muslim, since we have no way of knowing what is in his heart until he decides to act out on it.
A Muslim In Name Only [MINO] who decides to get serious about his Islamic religion soon finds out that jihad is an essential element of Islam. A core tenet.
This isn't some fringe teaching that nobody cares about. It is a central purpose of Islam. Jihad is obligatory for all Muslims until all non-Muslims have been subjugated to Islamic law.
After one’s Islamic belief, jihad to advance Islamic dominance is a Muslim’s crowning achievement.
Sahih Bukhari: V1B2N25:
“Allah’s Apostle was asked, ‘What is the best deed?’ He replied, ‘To believe in Allah and His Apostle Muhammad.’ The questioner then asked, ‘What is the next best in goodness? He replied, To participate in Jihad, religious fighting in Allah's Cause.’”
This political goal is a Muslim's religious duty. Muhammad didn't approve of sitting around knobbing your palm. He said the way to prove your devotion to Allah is by action.
Koran 4: 95:
“Allah prefers Jihadists who strive hard and fight above those who sit home. He has distinguished his fighters with a huge reward.”
And what is this “huge reward”?
Islam teaches that one can never be certain of his or her ultimate salvation. The only sure way to enter paradise is to die in an act of martyrdom for Allah. That's how you get a Muslim terrorist.
And that’s what makes Islam so dangerous Any Westernised Muslim who may have gone off the rails a bit is easy meat for a jihadi recruiter.
A Westernised Muslim is often caught between living as a Muslim, and living in a more secular, Western manner.
His alienation, both from his cultural roots and the wider Westernised milieu in which he moves, can be readily exploited by someone offering a sense of identity, purpose, and belonging.
The new recruit learns that by recommitting to Islam and becoming shahid, once the first drop of his blood is shed for Allah, all his sins are forgiven and he is guaranteed paradise.
This explains why in advance of carrying out their pre-planned attack, many of the 9/11 terrorists reportedly drank alcohol, ate pork, and visited nudie bars, things normally haram [forbidden] in Islam.
Not only are his own sins forgiven, but the shahid gets to intercede on Judgement Day for seventy family members, who will be spared from the hellfire and enter paradise in honor of the martyr.
Sunan Abi Dawud 2522: Book 15, Hadith 46:
“The Prophet said: The intercession of a martyr will be accepted for seventy members of his family.”
Highly attractive to someone who fell into secular, un-Islamic ways and returns to Islam wanting to make it up to his family and to Allah.
This, I think, explains why the second- and third-generations of immigrant stock are disproportionately involved in terrorist activity.
I’d be interested to read your thesis as referred to above, since it’s not something I’d been previously exposed to or considered.
My essay below suggests another psycho-sexual stand to the development of the jihadi impulse.
Something not usually reported is that unmarried Muslim men denied access to women typically experience sex first with other males.
While Islam prohibits adult homosexuality, man-boy sex is tacitly condoned because the boy is not considered a man yet.
Muslim men acting out sexually with boys argue that falling in love with or identifying as a homosexual man is the ultimate sin. Consequently, they reframe the exploitation of a young boy as a transactional act of physical gratification or dominance rather than an emotional relationship.
Because the boy is prepubescent or adolescent and lacks a beard, he is treated structurally as a possession rather than a "man," allowing the abuser to maintain his public standing as a straight, masculine figure within a deeply homophobic society.
This rationalisation is particularly prevalent in countries like Pakistan and Afghanistan, where they even have a saying: “Women are for babies, boys are for pleasure.”
Female doctors working with Afghan women in Northern Pakistan refugee camps reported a startling phenomenon: an epidemic of married women experiencing difficulty in falling pregnant and seeking medical advice for this problem.
Examination overwhelmingly disclosed no medical reasons for this. Follow-up questioning disclosed the women’s husbands were copulating with their wives solely in the manner they’d learned through their early sexual experiences with other males.
In a culture in which sex is never publicly discussed, neither husbands nor wives knew any better.
In Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Gaza, Egypt, and other Middle Eastern countries, the phrase “breaking his eye” is used to describe male-on-male anal rape. It is typically deployed by an older aggressor to boast about his dominance over a younger, weaker boy.
A troubling example of this mindset occurred in Germany, where a ten-year-old native German boy was rapied in a playground toilet by a married Muslim asylum seeker, whose wife had remained behind in his country of origin.
The attacker told the judge “it was a sexual emergency,” further underscoring the dangerous sexual attitudes that Muslim migrants may bring with them.
It is clear that for many Muslim men, sex is not about mutuality, but about the achievement of pleasure through the violent domination of others, often making sense of one’s own pederastic abuse by visiting it upon others.
Part of the jihad impulse may be explained as the terrorist violating the masculinity of the Kuffaar, just his masculinity was once violated.